Corporate trends / Performance record
Unfair Dismissal Case on “Re-Disciplinary Action and Disciplinary Severity (Informal Speech to Superior and Prior Reprimand)” (Unfair Dismissal 630)
- Date2026/08/17 00:00
- Read 3
[Case Information]
This case is a decision in which the employer prevailed (application dismissed) on the issues of “re-disciplinary action and disciplinary severity (use of informal speech to a superior and prior record of reprimand).”
Date of decision: 2026-07-07 · Decision body: Gyeonggi Regional Labor Relations Commission · Case No.: 2026Buhae1713
Summary of key issues:
A. Whether grounds for discipline existed
It cannot be deemed a violation of the principle of ne bis in idem or the principle of good faith merely because, upon cancelling the original disciplinary disposition and imposing a new disciplinary sanction, the grounds for the re-discipline are mostly the same as those for the original discipline. As the employee failed to present any objective evidence capable of overturning the grounds for discipline previously recognized in an earlier decision, all grounds for discipline were found to be established.
B. Whether the level of discipline was appropriate
The employee showed no remorse, such as by refusing to acknowledge the grounds for discipline, and, in light of the employee’s prior reprimand for using informal speech to a superior, and other factors, the Commission found that…
1. Legal Implications
This unfair dismissal case concerned the legitimacy of a re-imposed suspension in dispute before the Gyeonggi Regional Labor Relations Commission, and is a case in which the Commission found that the grounds for discipline, the severity of the sanction, and the disciplinary procedures were all justified. Labor Law Firm Law& has handled numerous collective redundancy and disciplinary cases involving hospitals and medical institutions, and this decision can serve as an important reference for HR and labor-management practices in medical institutions.
Ⅰ. Case Overview
The employer had previously imposed a reprimand on a hospital employee for reasons including the use of informal speech toward a superior. Subsequently, based on additional misconduct, the employer imposed a disciplinary sanction, and later, accepting the view that the original level of discipline was excessive, cancelled the original sanction and re-imposed discipline in the form of a one-month suspension. The employee argued that the re-discipline violated the principle of ne bis in idem and that the grounds, severity, and procedures of the disciplinary action were all unjust, and filed an application for remedy for unfair dismissal (unfair discipline). The Gyeonggi Regional Labor Relations Commission ruled in favor of the employer.
Ⅱ. Summary of Issues
The issues in this case were whether, after the employer voluntarily cancelled the original disciplinary sanction, the re-imposition of discipline based on the same or similar grounds violated the principle of ne bis in idem or the principle of good faith, whether the one-month suspension imposed as re-discipline was excessive in light of the grounds for discipline, and whether there were any procedural defects in the disciplinary process.
Ⅲ. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Reasoning
The panel in this case held that it is difficult to view the employer’s conduct as violating the principle of ne bis in idem or the principle of good faith merely because the employer cancelled the original sanction and re-imposed a reduced level of discipline. The panel noted that the employee failed to present any new objective evidence capable of overturning the grounds for discipline already recognized in a prior decision; that the employee had previously been reprimanded for using informal speech toward a superior and showed no remorse whatsoever, continuing to deny the grounds for discipline; and that, given the nature of hospital organizations, a certain level of severe discipline appears necessary to maintain order.
In light of these factors, the Commission found that a one-month suspension could not be regarded, in comparison with the grounds for discipline, as so manifestly unreasonable in light of social norms as to constitute an abuse of the employer’s discretionary authority in determining discipline. The Commission also found no procedural defects in the disciplinary process, noting that the employee had been given an opportunity to explain in writing via a written questionnaire and to appear and make statements before the personnel committee. On this basis, the Commission held that the dismissal in this case was not unfair.
Ⅳ. Practical Points (From the Employee’s Perspective)
From the employee’s standpoint, it should be borne in mind that, to overturn grounds for discipline already recognized by a Labor Relations Commission or court, mere assertions are insufficient; new objective evidence capable of negating those grounds must be presented. Furthermore, disciplinary measures such as suspension or pay reduction are not automatically recognized as unfair dismissal. Employees should cool-headedly review the circumstances leading to the discipline and their own attitude (whether they have shown remorse, efforts to prevent recurrence, etc.), and, if necessary, consult experts such as Labor Law Firm Law& to clearly identify whether the key issues lie in the “grounds, severity, or procedure” of the discipline and respond accordingly.
Ⅴ. Practical Points (From the Employer/Company Perspective)
From the employer’s perspective, this decision confirms that, where a disciplinary disposition is found to be defective, it is permissible not merely to suspend its execution but, where necessary, to cancel the original sanction and re-impose discipline at an appropriate level. However, employers must thoroughly secure objective evidence capable of proving the existence of the grounds for discipline, and must meticulously ensure procedural fairness by, for example, providing an opportunity for written explanation before convening the disciplinary committee, and guaranteeing the employee’s right to attend and make statements before the committee. The level of discipline should be designed so as not to be excessive in light of social norms, taking into comprehensive account the nature and degree of the misconduct, any prior disciplinary record, and the characteristics of the organization.
2. Matters Decided
A. Case Overview and Procedural History
A case in which the grounds, severity, and procedures of the disciplinary action were all found to be justified.
3. Summary of Decision
A. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Reasoning
(1) Whether grounds for discipline existed
It cannot be deemed a violation of the principle of ne bis in idem or the principle of good faith merely because, upon cancelling the original disciplinary disposition and imposing a new disciplinary sanction, the grounds for the re-discipline are mostly the same as those for the original discipline. As the employee failed to present any objective evidence capable of overturning the grounds for discipline previously recognized in an earlier decision, all grounds for discipline were found to be established.
(2) Whether the level of discipline was appropriate
The employee showed no remorse, such as by refusing to acknowledge the grounds for discipline, and had already been reprimanded for using informal speech toward a superior. The employer accepted a prior decision that the original level of discipline was excessive and reduced the sanction to a one-month suspension through re-discipline. In light of these factors, as well as the apparent need for severe discipline to maintain order in the hospital, the Commission determined that the one-month suspension could not be regarded, in light of social norms, as so manifestly unreasonable as to fall outside the bounds of the employer’s discretionary authority.
(3) Whether the disciplinary procedures were lawful
As the employee submitted a written questionnaire and appeared before the personnel committee to provide explanations, there were no procedural defects in the disciplinary process.
[See More Related Decisions]
- “Unfair Dismissal Decision on Disciplinary Severity (Participation in Services for Another Institution)”
- “Unfair Dismissal Decision on Remedial Interest and Refusal to Rehire (Post-Retirement Fixed-Term Employment)”
- “Unfair Dismissal Decision on Excessive Disciplinary Severity (Negligent Management and Supervision)”
[Tags]
Unfair dismissal, re-disciplinary action and disciplinary severity (informal speech to superior and prior reprimand), disciplinary dismissal, Labor Law Firm Law&, large labor law firm, Samseong-dong labor law firm, Samseong Station labor law firm, Gangnam labor law firm
※ This article is part of Labor Law Firm Law&’s “Unfair Dismissal Decisions” series.
※ The previous article, “Unfair Dismissal Decision on Voluntary Discontinuation of Participation (General Employment for Persons with Intellectual Disabilities),” can be viewed in a new window.
※ The list of decisions related to re-disciplinary action and disciplinary severity (informal speech to superior and prior reprimand) can be found in the “List of Decisions on Re-Disciplinary Action and Disciplinary Severity (Informal Speech to Superior and Prior Reprimand).”
※ Korean version of this case: Korean article
