Corporate trends / Performance record
Unfair Dismissal Decision on “Establishment of Employment Relationship (Daily Worker Employment Contract)” (Unfair Dismissal 631)
- Date2026/08/17 00:00
- Read 3
[Case Information]
This case is a decision in which the employer prevailed (application dismissed) on the issue of “establishment of an employment relationship (daily worker employment contract).”
Decision date: 2026-07-07 · Decision body: Gyeonggi Regional Labor Relations Commission · Case No.: 2026부해2803
Key issue summary: (1) The employee’s employment contract did not specify a contract period, and the contract stated that “this is a daily worker employment contract under which the employment relationship is created on a daily basis, and for practical convenience, it is deemed that the same daily worker employment contract is concluded for each working day without separate contractual procedures.”
1. Legal Implications
Ⅰ. Case Overview
In this case, the employee believed that he had been working as a regular (non-daily) employee, whereas the employer treated him as a daily worker and excluded him from work. The dispute concerned whether this exclusion constituted an unfair dismissal. The Gyeonggi Regional Labor Relations Commission focused on the contents of the written employment contract and the actual manner in which the relationship was operated to determine the nature of the employment relationship, and dismissed the application for relief from unfair dismissal.
The issue in this case was:
“Where the employment contract clearly states that the employee is a ‘daily worker whose employment relationship is created and terminated on a daily basis,’ and in practice the decision on whether the employee works is made on a day‑to‑day basis, does the employer’s exclusion of the employee from providing work constitute an unfair dismissal?”
Ⅱ. Summary of Issues
The key issues examined by the Labor Relations Commission in this case were, first, whether the employee held the status of an “employee with no fixed term” under the Labor Standards Act, or a status equivalent to that of a fixed‑term employee whose contract had been repeatedly renewed over a long period; and second, if the employment contract was that of a daily worker whose contract terminated on a one‑day basis, whether the employer’s act of excluding the employee from work after a certain date could be regarded as a “dismissal.”
Ⅲ. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Reasoning
The panel in this case noted that the employment contract submitted by the employer specifically stated that “this is a daily worker employment contract under which the employment relationship is created on a daily basis, and for practical convenience, it is deemed that the same daily worker employment contract is concluded for each working day without separate contractual procedures”; that the employee, upon joining the company, personally reviewed and signed the employment contract, and at the hearing acknowledged the wording of the contract but stated that he had misunderstood it as a regular employment contract; and that the employer did not set predetermined working days but decided daily whether the employee would work depending on the workload, and there was no evidence that the employee had raised any objection to this.
In light of these circumstances, the Commission found that the employment relationship between the employee and the employer constituted a daily worker employment contract under which the employment terminated on a one‑day basis. As a result, because the employment relationship naturally terminated at the end of each working day, the employer’s failure to request the employee’s services after a certain point in time could not be regarded as a dismissal under the Labor Standards Act. Accordingly, the application for relief from unfair dismissal filed with the Labor Relations Commission was rejected on the ground that no dismissal had been established in the first place.
Ⅳ. Practical Points (From the Employee’s Perspective)
From the employee’s perspective, it is essential to confirm what type of employment contract you have actually entered into, and in particular how terms such as “daily worker,” “daily contract,” and “contract period” are set out in the employment contract. If the contract clearly provides for a daily worker structure and, in practice, whether you work has been determined each day depending on whether the employer calls you in, you must bear in mind that it may be difficult to have the situation legally recognized as “unfair dismissal” merely because there is no call to work after a certain point.
Even where short‑term daily employment has been repeated over a long period, if no separate practice of renewal or reasonable expectation of continued employment has been formed, it is important to understand that the courts and Labor Relations Commissions are still likely to treat the relationship as daily employment and to deny that a dismissal has been established.
Ⅴ. Practical Points (From the Employer/Company’s Perspective)
From the employer’s perspective, if you intend to operate your workforce as daily workers in practice, it is important to clearly state in the employment contract that the relationship is that of a “daily worker whose employment relationship is created and terminated on a one‑day basis,” and to avoid wording on predetermined working days or contract periods that could be misunderstood as indicating regular employment. In addition, in actual operation, it is helpful for preventing disputes to decide individually each day whether the employee will work depending on the workload, and to explain and notify this in a way that allows the employee to consistently recognize it.
Furthermore, if daily workers are in fact used continuously over a long period in a manner similar to regular employees—such as operating schedules on the assumption of continuous work or conducting personnel management similar to that for regular employees (regular evaluations, operation premised on renewal, etc.)—the Labor Relations Commission or the courts may later recharacterize the substance of the relationship as an “employment contract with no fixed term” and apply the legal principles governing redundancy or unfair dismissal. It is therefore necessary to align the contractual form with the actual operation.
This decision of the Gyeonggi Regional Labor Relations Commission clearly illustrates that, in unfair dismissal relief procedures, not only the status as an employee but also the very “existence of a dismissal” must be established, and that, in particular for daily or short‑term contract structures, the wording of the employment contract and the actual mode of operation are the starting point for determining whether a dismissal has occurred. Those preparing an application for relief from unfair dismissal before the Labor Relations Commission are advised to first accurately review their employment type and contract structure, with the assistance of experts such as Labor Law Firm Law&, and then formulate their relief strategy.
2. Matters Decided
A. Case Overview and Procedural History
A case in which it was held that, because the employee fell under the category of a daily worker, no dismissal had been established.
3. Gist of the Decision
A. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Reasoning
(1) The employee’s employment contract did not specify a contract period, and the contract specifically stated that “this is a daily worker employment contract under which the employment relationship is created on a daily basis, and for practical convenience, it is deemed that the same daily worker employment contract is concluded for each working day without separate contractual procedures”; (2) the employee, upon joining the company, reviewed the contents of the employment contract and personally signed it, and at the hearing stated, “Because the working period was not specified in the employment contract, I misunderstood it as regular employment”; and (3) the employer, without specifying predetermined working days in the employment contract, determined daily whether the employee would work depending on the workload, and there was no evidence that the employee had raised any objection to this. In light of all these circumstances, the Commission determined that the employment relationship between the employee and the employer was a daily worker employment contract under which the employment terminated on a one‑day basis, and therefore that no dismissal had been established.
[See More Related Decisions]
- “Unfair Dismissal Decision Relating to ‘Business Necessity (Reassignment of Cleaner)’”
- “Unfair Dismissal Decision Relating to ‘Expression of Intent to Resign (Resignation Remark in Telephone Call)’”
- “Unfair Dismissal Decision Relating to ‘Non‑Establishment of Hiring Decision (Absence of Offer Letter)’” – Decision date: – Case No.: Initial decision upheld
[Tags]
Unfair dismissal, establishment of employment relationship (daily worker employment contract), others, Labor Law Firm Law&, large labor law firm, Samseong‑dong labor law firm, Samseong Station labor law firm, Gangnam labor law firm
※ This article is part of the “Unfair Dismissal Decisions” series by Labor Law Firm Law&.
※ The previous article, “Unfair Dismissal Decision Relating to ‘Re‑Disciplinary Action and Appropriateness of Disciplinary Measure (Disrespectful Language and Prior Reprimand)’,” can be viewed in a new window.
※ A list of decisions relating to the establishment of employment relationships (daily worker employment contracts) can be found under “List of Decisions Relating to Establishment of Employment Relationship (Daily Worker Employment Contract).”
※ Korean version of this case: Korean article
