Corporate trends / Performance record
Unfair Dismissal Case on Disciplinary Severity (Repeated Verbal Abuse and Family Denigration) (Unfair Dismissal 761)
- Date2026/10/02 00:00
- Read 3
[Case Information]
This case is a decision in which the employer ultimately prevailed (application dismissed) on the issue of “disciplinary severity (repeated verbal abuse and family denigration).”
Decision date: 2026-07-29 · Labor Relations Commission: Gyeonggi Regional Labor Relations Commission · Case No.: 2026Buhae1971
Summary of key issues:
A. Legitimacy of grounds for discipline
The verbal abuse and family-denigrating remarks toward the complainant, which the employer cited as grounds for discipline, were sufficiently confirmed through audio recordings, and the employee also admitted to having engaged in verbal abuse. In light of these factors, the grounds for discipline were found to be legitimate.
B. Appropriateness of the level of discipline
(1) The employee’s verbal abuse toward the complainant occurred repeatedly and continuously, and seriously exceeded the socially acceptable limits; (2) the employee showed no sign of remorse; (3) although suspension without pay of up to three months was possible, the employer’s assertion that it decided on a three-day suspension in consideration of the need for the employee to continue operating the business site was found to be persuasive; and (4) the financial loss to the employee from a three-day suspension was not substantial, and there appeared to be no other particularly serious disadvantage. Taken together, the level of discipline was found to be appropriate.
1. Legal Implications
Ⅰ. Case Overview
In this case, an employee received a three-day suspension without pay from the employer for repeatedly directing verbal abuse and family-denigrating remarks at the complainant. The employee then filed an application with the Labor Relations Commission, claiming that the suspension constituted unfair discipline equivalent to unfair dismissal. The Gyeonggi Regional Labor Relations Commission reviewed the existence of grounds for discipline, the appropriateness of the level of discipline, and the lawfulness of the disciplinary procedures, and concluded that the employer’s disciplinary action was justified.
The key issue in this case is whether a three-day suspension imposed for repeated verbal abuse and family-denigrating remarks in the workplace is justified in terms of the grounds, severity, and procedures of the disciplinary action.
Ⅱ. Summary of Issues
The issues in this case are: first, whether the employee’s verbal abuse and family-denigrating remarks fall within the grounds for discipline set out in the work rules; second, whether, in light of the content, frequency, and degree of such conduct, a three-day suspension is not excessive by social standards; and third, whether the disciplinary procedures were lawfully conducted, including whether the employee was given a sufficient opportunity to explain and defend himself or herself during the disciplinary process.
Ⅲ. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Findings
The panel in this case found, based on the audio recordings submitted by the employer and other evidence, that there had been multiple instances of verbal abuse and family-denigrating remarks; that the employee himself or herself admitted to the fact of having engaged in verbal abuse; and that the content of the remarks clearly exceeded what is socially acceptable. In light of these factors, the panel held that the grounds for discipline were legitimate.
The panel also found that the level of discipline was appropriate, considering that the verbal abuse had been continuous and repeated; that the employee appeared to show no remorse; that the employer’s assertion that it decided on a three-day suspension, even though a suspension of up to three months was possible under the work rules, in consideration of the operational need for the employee to continue running the business site, was quite persuasive; and that the wage loss resulting from a three-day suspension was not significant and no other particularly serious disadvantage to the employee could be recognized.
In addition, the panel found that the disciplinary procedures were lawful, noting that there was no material defect in the process, such as a failure to provide the employee with a sufficient opportunity to explain and defend himself or herself, and that there was no indication that the disciplinary procedures required under the collective agreement or work rules had been violated. As a result, the panel held that there was no dismissal in this case and that the three-day suspension at issue could not be regarded as unfair.
Ⅳ. Practical Points (From the Employee’s Perspective)
From the employee’s perspective, it should be borne in mind that verbal abuse in the workplace—especially remarks denigrating the other party’s family—can constitute grounds for discipline that seriously undermine corporate order, rather than being treated as mere emotional outbursts. Where verbal abuse is not a one-time incident but occurs repeatedly, and the employee is later assessed as lacking remorse, there is a high likelihood that serious disciplinary measures such as suspension or wage reduction will be deemed appropriate.
Furthermore, in order to challenge discipline as unfair, it is not sufficient merely to argue that “there were no grounds.” Even if the grounds are acknowledged, the employee must substantiate, with specific facts and evidence, whether the level of discipline is excessive by social standards and whether the right to defense was infringed during the procedures, in line with the legal principles applicable to each element. As the Labor Relations Commission and the courts base their determinations primarily on objective materials submitted at the time of discipline, it is advisable to prepare in advance a detailed written explanation of the circumstances, statements of remorse, efforts to reconcile with the victim, and similar materials.
Ⅴ. Practical Points (From the Employer/Company’s Perspective)
From the employer’s perspective, when verbal abuse, insults, or other acts infringing on personal dignity occur in the workplace, it is necessary to secure sufficient objective evidence—such as written statements, audio recordings, and CCTV footage—to prove the existence of grounds for discipline. In addition, while referring to the disciplinary severity standards in the work rules, the employer should determine the level of discipline at a degree that is not excessive by social standards, taking into comprehensive account the nature and frequency of the misconduct, the employee’s attitude, and the impact on the organization.
From a procedural standpoint, it is important to keep records demonstrating faithful compliance with internal rules on prior notice, opportunities for explanation and statement, and the composition and resolution procedures of the disciplinary committee, so that procedural legitimacy can be readily recognized by the Labor Relations Commission. In particular, even for relatively short-term disciplinary measures such as suspension or wage reduction, the employer should thoroughly guarantee procedural rights at a level comparable to dismissal, in anticipation of potential future disputes.
As shown in this case, a finding that discipline is justified requires that all three elements—existence of grounds for discipline, appropriateness of the level of discipline, and lawfulness of the disciplinary procedures—be satisfied. To prevent and respond to similar cases, employers are advised to review their regulations and procedures in advance with the assistance of a specialized labor law firm such as Labor Law Firm Law&.
2. Matters Decided
A. Case Overview and Procedural History
This is a case in which the three-day suspension was found to be justified on the grounds that the reasons for discipline were legitimate, the level of discipline was appropriate, and the disciplinary procedures were lawful.
3. Summary of the Decision
A. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Findings
a. Legitimacy of the grounds for discipline
The verbal abuse and family-denigrating remarks toward the complainant, which the employer cited as grounds for discipline, were sufficiently confirmed through audio recordings and other evidence, and the employee also admitted to having engaged in verbal abuse. In light of these factors, the grounds for discipline were legitimate.
b. Appropriateness of the level of discipline
(1) The employee’s verbal abuse and similar conduct toward the complainant occurred repeatedly and continuously, and seriously exceeded the range permissible by social norms;
(2) the employee appeared to show no remorse;
(3) although a suspension of up to three months was possible, the employer’s assertion that it decided on a “three-day suspension” in consideration of the fact that the employee had to lead the operation of the business site appeared persuasive; and
(4) the financial loss to the employee resulting from a three-day suspension was not substantial, and there appeared to be no other serious disadvantage to the employee beyond the financial loss.
In light of these factors, the level of discipline was appropriate.
c. Lawfulness of the disciplinary procedures
As the employer provided the employee with a sufficient opportunity to explain and defend himself or herself and there was no particular defect apparent in the disciplinary procedures, the procedures were lawful.
[Further Related Decisions]
- ‘Disciplinary Severity (Participation in Services for Another Institution)’ Unfair Dismissal Decision
- ‘Excessive Disciplinary Severity (Negligent Management and Supervision)’ Unfair Dismissal Decision
- ‘Business Necessity (Reassignment of Cleaning Staff)’ Unfair Dismissal Decision
[Tags]
Unfair dismissal, disciplinary severity (repeated verbal abuse and family denigration), disciplinary dismissal (disciplinary action), workplace harassment, Labor Law Firm Law&, large labor law firm, Samseong-dong labor law firm, Samseong Station labor law firm, Gangnam labor law firm
※ This article is part of the “Unfair Dismissal Decisions” series by Labor Law Firm Law&.
※ You can view the previous article, “‘Non-Existence of Legitimate Expectation of Renewal (No Repeated Renewal Cases)’ Unfair Dismissal Decision,” in a new window.
※ You can view the list of decisions related to disciplinary severity (repeated verbal abuse and family denigration) on the “List of Decisions Related to Disciplinary Severity (Repeated Verbal Abuse and Family Denigration)” page.
※ Korean version of this case: Korean article
