Labor law firm Law&

Corporate performance /
Consultation inquiry

    Corporate trends / Performance record

    ‘Disciplinary Severity (Attempted Extortion Misconduct)’ Unfair Dismissal Decision (Unfair Dismissal 763)
    • Date2026/10/03 00:00
    • Read 3
    [Case Information] This case is a decision in which the employer ultimately prevailed (application dismissed) on the issue of “propriety of disciplinary severity (misconduct constituting attempted extortion).” Decision date: 2026-07-29 · Decision body: Ulsan Regional Labor Relations Commission · Case No.: 2026Buhae217 Key issues in summary: A. Existence of grounds for discipline (1) Threatening remarks made during an interview, using the possible leakage of the company’s business information as leverage; (2) unauthorized collection of client information lists and a collection of business cards of suppliers unrelated to the employee’s duties; (3) private possession and indications of internal and external dissemination of sales-related materials. These acts, constituting a breach of the duty to maintain confidentiality in the course of employment, were found to amount to a cause attributable to the employee such that, under social norms, the employment relationship could no longer be maintained, and thus were recognized as grounds for discipline. 1. Legal Implications Ⅰ. Case Overview In this case, the employee was dismissed for cause after making threatening remarks that referred to the company’s business and other confidential information and demanding a large sum of money (attempted extortion). The employee then filed an application for relief from unfair dismissal. In the proceedings before the Ulsan Regional Labor Relations Commission, the Commission comprehensively reviewed the existence of grounds for discipline, the appropriateness of the level of discipline, and the lawfulness of the disciplinary procedures, based on the documents and statements submitted by the employer. Ⅱ. Summary of Issues The issues in this case are whether “threatening remarks made by referring to confidential information, demands for a large sum of money, and indications of unauthorized collection, possession, and dissemination of business information constitute a cause attributable to the employee such that, under social norms, the employment relationship can no longer be maintained, thereby providing just cause for dismissal; and whether, in that process, the disciplinary procedures and the level of discipline were proper.” Ⅲ. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Findings The panel in this case, in light of the interview records, the circumstances under which materials were obtained, and related facts presented by the employer, found that (1) threatening remarks were made during the interview, using the possible leakage of the company’s business information as leverage; (2) the employee had collected, without authorization, client information lists and a collection of business cards of suppliers unrelated to his or her duties; and (3) there were indications that the employee had privately possessed and disseminated sales-related materials inside and outside the company. On this basis, the panel held that the employee had breached the duty to maintain confidentiality in the course of employment. The dismissal in this case was found to be justified on the grounds that the above misconduct fundamentally destroyed the duty of good faith and the mutual trust relationship between the company and the employee, and further constituted serious unlawful conduct rising to the level of attempted extortion under criminal law; that, under social norms, it had become difficult to continue the employment relationship; and that procedural safeguards had been observed, including written notice of the specific grounds for discipline and dismissal before and after the convening of the disciplinary committee, and provision of approximately 10 days’ advance notice of attendance and an opportunity to be heard. Ⅳ. Practical Points (From the Employee’s Perspective) Employees should be mindful that using business information, client lists, and other confidential information obtained in the course of employment as a personal bargaining tool, or privately retaining or leaking such information, goes beyond a mere rules violation and can fundamentally destroy the relationship of trust, thereby constituting grounds for disciplinary dismissal equivalent to a redundancy dismissal. In particular, conduct in which an employee hints at “information leakage” during an interview while demanding money or other benefits may give rise to criminal liability for attempted extortion. It is therefore important to manage oneself so as not to cross legal and ethical boundaries, even in conflict situations. Ⅴ. Practical Points (From the Employer’s Perspective) From the employer’s standpoint, it is important to clearly stipulate in the rules of employment and HR regulations the duty to maintain confidentiality in the course of employment and the possibility of disciplinary dismissal in the event of leakage of business information. When an incident actually occurs, the employer should systematically secure evidence so as to meet the burden of proof required by the Labor Relations Commission and the courts, by specifically organizing the facts of the misconduct. In addition, as in this case, strictly observing procedures—such as providing written notice of the grounds for discipline before and after the disciplinary committee meeting and affording a sufficient opportunity to explain—is key to prevailing in unfair dismissal disputes. This decision of the Ulsan Regional Labor Relations Commission clearly illustrates that, in unfair dismissal disputes, the “Labor Relations Commission” regards on-the-job confidential information leakage and threatening conduct amounting to attempted extortion as very serious misconduct, and that where the grounds, procedures, and level of discipline are all satisfied, it may broadly recognize the legitimacy of disciplinary dismissal. Both employees and employers should fully understand these legal principles and, for the prevention and handling of similar disputes, seek timely advice from a specialized labor law firm such as Labor Law Firm Law&. 2. Matters Decided A. Case Overview and Procedural History This is a case in which it was held that there existed causes attributable to the employee—such as threatening remarks made by referring to confidential information and demands for a large sum of money (attempted extortion)—such that, under social norms, the employment relationship could no longer be maintained; that the disciplinary procedures were lawful; and that the level of discipline was appropriate, and therefore the disciplinary dismissal was justified. 3. Summary of Decision A. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Findings A. Existence of Grounds for Discipline (1) Threatening remarks made during an interview, using the possible leakage of the company’s business information as leverage; (2) unauthorized collection of client information lists and a collection of business cards of suppliers unrelated to the employee’s duties; and (3) private possession and indications of internal and external dissemination of sales-related materials—these acts, constituting a breach of the duty to maintain confidentiality in the course of employment, were found to amount to a cause attributable to the employee such that, under social norms, the employment relationship could no longer be maintained, and thus were recognized as grounds for discipline. B. Appropriateness of the Level of Discipline The employee’s misconduct fundamentally destroyed the “duty of good faith” and the “mutual trust relationship” that form the basis of the employment relationship, and further constituted serious misconduct amounting to unlawful conduct under criminal law (attempted extortion). Accordingly, the level of discipline—dismissal—was found to be appropriate. C. Lawfulness of the Disciplinary Procedures The employer notified the employee in writing of the specific grounds for discipline and dismissal before and after the convening of the disciplinary committee, and approximately 10 days before the committee meeting gave notice to appear and an opportunity to explain. Therefore, the procedures for discipline were found to be free from defects. [See More Related Decisions] - “Unfair Dismissal Decision on ‘Propriety of Disciplinary Severity (Participation in Services for Another Institution)’” - “Unfair Dismissal Decision on ‘Excessive Disciplinary Severity (Negligent Management and Supervision)’” - “Unfair Dismissal Decision on ‘Expectation of Employment Succession (Competitive Bidding for Logistics Center)’” [Tags] Unfair dismissal, propriety of disciplinary severity (misconduct constituting attempted extortion), disciplinary dismissal, violation of company policy · non-compliance with work instructions, others, Labor Law Firm Law&, large labor law firm, Samseong-dong labor law firm, Samseong Station labor law firm, Gangnam labor law firm ※ This article is part of the “Unfair Dismissal Decisions” series by Labor Law Firm Law&. ※ The previous article, “Unfair Dismissal Decision on ‘Propriety of Disciplinary Severity (Repeated Misconduct)’,” can be viewed in a new window. ※ The list of decisions related to propriety of disciplinary severity (misconduct constituting attempted extortion) can be viewed together under “List of Decisions on Propriety of Disciplinary Severity (Misconduct Constituting Attempted Extortion).” ※ Korean version of this case: Korean article
    ⚙