Corporate trends / Performance record
Unfair Dismissal Case Concerning the Existence of Dismissal (Absence of Consent to Resignation upon Employer’s Recommendation) (Unfair Dismissal 764)
- Date2026/10/03 00:00
- Read 3
[Case Information]
This case is a decision that concluded by upholding the first-instance ruling on the issue of “existence of dismissal (absence of consent to recommended resignation).”
Decision date: 2026-07-29 · Commission: Central Labor Relations Commission · Case No.: 2026Buhae261
Key issue summary:
A. Existence of dismissal
The employer asserted that it had recommended resignation to the employee and that the employee agreed, but there is no evidence proving that the employee explicitly agreed or otherwise consented.
1. Legal Implications
Ⅰ. Case Overview
The key question in this unfair dismissal case was whether the employee left the company because the employer recommended resignation and the employee agreed, or whether the employer unilaterally terminated the employment relationship, constituting a dismissal. The Central Labor Relations Commission examined the actual circumstances, including KakaoTalk messages, to determine whether a dismissal had occurred, and recognized the dismissal as unfair on the ground that the employer failed to notify the reasons for dismissal and the timing of dismissal in writing, in violation of procedural requirements. The Commission accepted the employee’s application for an order of monetary compensation.
This decision illustrates how the Labor Relations Commission evaluates the form of termination of employment, and how strictly it interprets the written-notice obligation under Article 27 of the Labor Standards Act. It is also a type of case that Labor Law Firm Law& frequently refers to when advising on similar matters.
Ⅱ. Summary of Issues
The issue in this case was whether, in the course of recommending resignation, where the employer notified the employee that “it seems we have to terminate the employment relationship as of today” and “do not come to work from tomorrow,” such a situation can be regarded as a dismissal rather than a voluntary resignation or termination by mutual agreement, and, if it is a dismissal, whether a dismissal that does not satisfy the written-notice requirement under Article 27 of the Labor Standards Act can be valid.
Ⅲ. Key Points of the Labor Relations Commission’s Decision
With respect to the “agreement to resign” asserted by the employer, the panel found that there was no evidence at all proving that the employee explicitly agreed, or that the employee consented in any other way. It further noted that the employer stated to the employee, “it seems we have to terminate the employment relationship as of today,” and sent a KakaoTalk message via another staff member stating, “do not come to work from tomorrow,” and that the circumstances clearly showed that the employer’s unilateral intention to terminate the employment relationship had been communicated to the employee.
On this basis, the panel determined that the employer’s conduct did not constitute a recommendation to resign or a termination by mutual agreement, but rather a dismissal unilaterally severing the employment relationship.
In addition, the panel held that the employer, in dismissing the employee, failed to notify in writing the reasons for dismissal and the timing of dismissal as required under Article 27 of the Labor Standards Act; that written notice of the reasons and timing of dismissal is an essential requirement for the effectiveness of a dismissal and cannot be substituted by ex post supplementation; and that the purpose of the written-notice system is to clarify the existence, timing, and reasons for dismissal in order to prevent disputes and guarantee the employee’s right of defense.
On these grounds, the panel ruled that the dismissal in this case was an unfair dismissal with a serious procedural defect.
The panel also considered that the employee expressly wished for monetary compensation rather than reinstatement to the original position, and that the relationship of trust between the parties had already been damaged to a degree that made restoration difficult. It therefore found it appropriate to grant the employee’s application for an order of monetary compensation.
Ⅳ. Practical Points (From the Employee’s Perspective)
From the employee’s perspective, if the employer gives notice in terms such as “do not come to work from tomorrow,” it is important to clearly recognize that, regardless of whether it is labeled a resignation or recommended resignation, if in substance it is a unilateral termination by the employer, it constitutes a dismissal. If you have been dismissed, it is crucial for purposes of filing a relief application with the Labor Relations Commission to check whether the reasons and timing of dismissal were notified in writing, and to carefully keep records of any notices exchanged via text message, KakaoTalk, email, or other means that leave evidence.
In particular, even if the employer claims that “the employee agreed to resign,” if there is no written resignation letter or clear circumstances showing consent, there is a high likelihood that the situation will be recognized as a dismissal. If you feel you have been unfairly dismissed, you should promptly consult with experts such as the Labor Relations Commission or Labor Law Firm Law&.
Ⅴ. Practical Points (From the Employer’s/Company’s Perspective)
From the employer’s perspective, it is important to clearly understand the legal distinction between “recommended resignation” and “dismissal” when terminating an employment relationship. If the employee is resigning voluntarily, you must obtain a resignation letter that specifically states the employee’s intention to resign and the resignation date, or otherwise secure documentation that can later prove in a dispute that the termination was by mutual agreement.
If you decide to dismiss an employee, you must notify the reasons for dismissal and the timing of dismissal in writing, in advance of the dismissal taking effect, in accordance with Article 27 of the Labor Standards Act. You should note that a mere oral notice or a KakaoTalk message such as “do not come in from tomorrow” does not satisfy these requirements. If these basic procedures are not followed, the Labor Relations Commission is highly likely to find unfair dismissal on the ground of procedural defects, even where there may be some substantive grounds for dismissal.
2. Matters Decided
A. Case Overview and Procedural History
A case in which the Commission found that a dismissal existed and that the dismissal was unfair because the employer failed to notify in writing the reasons for dismissal and the timing of dismissal.
3. Gist of the Decision
A. Key Points of the Labor Relations Commission’s Decision
A. Existence of Dismissal
The employer asserted that it had recommended resignation to the employee and that the employee agreed, but there is no evidence proving that the employee explicitly agreed or that the employee consented in any other way. The employer’s statement to the employee that “it seems we have to terminate the employment relationship as of today,” and the KakaoTalk message sent to the employee via another staff member stating “do not come to work from tomorrow,” constitute a dismissal unilaterally terminating the employment relationship.
B. Justifiability of the Dismissal
In dismissing the employee, the employer did not notify the reasons for dismissal and the timing of dismissal in writing, as required under Article 27 of the Labor Standards Act. This constitutes a procedural defect, and therefore the dismissal is unfair.
C. Acceptance of the Application for an Order of Monetary Compensation
Because the employee wishes to receive monetary compensation rather than reinstatement to the original position, and because it was determined that there is no relationship of trust sufficient to continue the employment relationship between the employer and the employee, it is appropriate to accept the employee’s application for an order of monetary compensation.
[See More Related Decisions]
- “Unfair Dismissal Decision on Disciplinary Severity (Participation in Services of Another Institution)”
- “Unfair Dismissal Decision on Relief Interest and Refusal to Rehire (Post-Retirement Fixed-Term Employment)”
- “Unfair Dismissal Decision on Business Necessity (Reassignment of Cleaning Staff)”
[Tags]
Unfair dismissal, existence of dismissal (absence of consent to recommended resignation), others, Labor Law Firm Law&, large labor law firm, Samseong-dong labor law firm, Samseong Station labor law firm, Gangnam labor law firm
※ This article is part of Labor Law Firm Law&’s “Unfair Dismissal Decisions” series.
※ You can view the previous article, “Unfair Dismissal Decision on Disciplinary Severity (Attempted Extortion Misconduct),” in a new window.
※ The list of decisions related to the existence of dismissal (absence of consent to recommended resignation) can be viewed together in the “List of Decisions on Existence of Dismissal (Absence of Consent to Recommended Resignation).”
※ Korean version of this case: Korean article
