Corporate trends / Performance record
‘Existence of Dismissal (Concurrent Childcare Leave and Industrial Accident Medical Care)’ Unfair Dismissal Decision (Unfair Dismissal 765)
- Date2026/10/03 00:00
- Read 3
[Case Information]
This case is a decision in which the employee partially prevailed on the issue of “existence of dismissal (concurrent childcare leave and industrial accident medical care).”
Decision date: 2026-07-29 · Decision body: Jeju Regional Labor Relations Commission · Case No.: 2026Buhae128
Key issue summary:
A. Existence and justification of dismissal
The employee argued that the employer’s continued refusal to allow reinstatement in effect constituted a dismissal. However, there was no notice of dismissal, no processing of removal or resignation, or other materials confirming the termination of the employment relationship, and even the employee could not clearly assert that the employment relationship had ended. Therefore, it is difficult to find that a dismissal existed.
1. Legal Implications
Ⅰ. Case Overview
In this case, while the employee was on childcare leave, the employee notified the employer that the grounds for childcare leave no longer existed and requested reinstatement. Nevertheless, the employer did not designate a work commencement date within the statutory period and refused reinstatement. The employee therefore filed an application with the Labor Relations Commission for relief from unfair dismissal and unfair leave.
The Jeju Regional Labor Relations Commission rendered its decision focusing on whether there was unfair dismissal, and, in parallel, whether the childcare leave had lawfully ended and whether the subsequent refusal to reinstate was justified.
Ⅱ. Summary of Issues
The issue in this case is whether, “after the employee clearly notified the employer of the grounds for termination of childcare leave, the employer’s failure to designate a work commencement date and refusal to reinstate constitutes a dismissal, and whether it constitutes unfair leave (complete exclusion from work) without just cause.”
Ⅲ. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Findings
The panel in this case found that, in light of the absence of explicit materials confirming the termination of the employment relationship—such as a written notice of dismissal or processing of removal/resignation—and the fact that the employee did not act on the premise that the employment relationship had ended,
it was difficult to find that a dismissal disposition in this case existed.
However, the panel also held that, since the employee personally applied for childcare leave and the employer approved it, the childcare leave itself was lawful and valid. Once the employee notified the employer that the employee was no longer living with the child and was not contributing to childrearing—grounds for termination of childcare leave—the employer was under a duty to designate a work commencement date within 30 days as prescribed by law and to prepare for the employee’s return.
Nonetheless, the employer continued to refuse the employee’s provision of labor on the grounds of interim measures related to stalking and the use of replacement personnel, without sufficiently substantiating circumstances that would make it unavoidable to exclude the employee entirely from work. Taking these factors together, the Commission found that the childcare leave ended as of 19 June 2026, and that the subsequent refusal to accept the employee’s work constituted unfair leave without just cause.
Ⅳ. Practical Points (From the Employee’s Perspective)
Even while you are on childcare leave, if the grounds for such leave no longer exist—for example, because you are no longer living with your child or are unable to provide childcare—you should notify your employer of that fact, specifying the exact date and reasons, in a manner that leaves evidence, such as in writing or by email.
If, thereafter, the company delays or refuses to designate a reinstatement date or to assign work, you may challenge this by filing an application for relief from unfair leave (complete exclusion from work) with the Labor Relations Commission. At that time, it is important to systematically organize the content and timing of your notification, as well as the company’s responses and the course of its actions.
Ⅴ. Practical Points (From the Employer/Company Perspective)
For discretionary leaves based on statute, such as childcare leave, you must bear in mind that, once the grounds for leave have ceased to exist or the employee has applied for reinstatement, you are under a duty to promptly allow reinstatement and clearly designate a work commencement date within 30 days.
Even where there are circumstances such as interim measures in a stalking case, the use of replacement personnel, or operational difficulties in running the organization, if the unavoidability of completely excluding the employee from work is not recognized, the measure may be found to constitute unfair leave. Where necessary, you should first consider alternative personnel measures such as job adjustments or reassignment.
This decision clearly demonstrates that, in the process of ending childcare leave and reinstatement, any measure by the employer to continue excluding the employee after the expiry of the leave period is subject to strict scrutiny, and that even if it does not amount to unfair dismissal, it may still constitute “unfair leave” and be subject to separate relief. Both employees and employers should design and implement notifications of the end of childcare leave and reinstatement procedures in careful compliance with the provisions of the Labor Standards Act and the Act on Gender Equality in Employment and Work-Family Reconciliation.
(ⓒ2026 copyright. Labor Attorney Youngseop Moon, Labor Law Firm Law&. Unauthorized reproduction and redistribution are prohibited.)
2. Matters Decided
A. Case Overview and Procedural History
A case in which it was held to constitute unfair leave where the employer, despite the employee’s notification of grounds for termination of childcare leave, did not designate a work commencement date within the statutory period and refused reinstatement.
3. Summary of Decision
A. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Findings
A. Existence and Justification of Dismissal
The employee argued that the employer’s continued refusal to allow reinstatement in effect constituted a dismissal. However, there were no materials such as a notice of dismissal or processing of removal/resignation confirming the termination of the employment relationship, and even the employee could not clearly assert that the employment relationship had ended. Therefore, it is difficult to find that a dismissal existed.
B. Justification of the Leave
The employee personally applied for childcare leave and the employer approved it. It is difficult to find that the approval of industrial accident medical care retroactively nullified childcare leave that had already commenced. Therefore, the childcare leave from 9 March 2026 was lawful and valid.
However, although on 20 May 2026 the employee notified the employer of grounds for termination of childcare leave—namely, that the employee was no longer living with the child and was not contributing to childrearing—the employer did not designate a work commencement date within 30 days, and the childcare leave therefore ended on 19 June 2026. Nevertheless, the employer continued to refuse the employee’s provision of labor from 20 June 2026 on the grounds of interim measures related to stalking and the use of replacement personnel. There were not sufficient circumstances to find that a complete exclusion from work was unavoidable, and thus this constituted unfair leave without just cause.
[See More Related Decisions]
- “Unfair Dismissal Decision on ‘Benefit of Remedy · Refusal to Rehire (Post-Retirement Fixed-Term Employment)’”
- “Unfair Dismissal Decision on ‘Business Necessity (Reassignment of Cleaning Staff)’”
- “Unfair Dismissal Decision on ‘Appropriateness of Disciplinary Measure (Participation in Services for Another Institution)’”
[Tags]
Unfair dismissal, existence of dismissal (concurrent childcare leave and industrial accident medical care), others, Labor Law Firm Law&, large labor law firm, Samseong-dong labor law firm, Samseong Station labor law firm, Gangnam labor law firm
※ This article is part of Labor Law Firm Law&’s “Unfair Dismissal Decisions” series.
※ You can view the previous article, “Unfair Dismissal Decision on ‘Existence of Dismissal (Absence of Consent to Voluntary Resignation)’,” in a new window.
※ A list of decisions related to the existence of dismissal (concurrent childcare leave and industrial accident medical care) can be found in the “List of Decisions on Existence of Dismissal (Concurrent Childcare Leave and Industrial Accident Medical Care).”
※ Korean version of this case: Korean article
