Corporate trends / Performance record
‘Automatic Retirement (Suspended Sentence of Imprisonment)’ Unfair Dismissal Decision (Unfair Dismissal 842)
- Date2026/11/20 00:00
- Read 3
[Case Information]
This case is a decision on the issue of “automatic retirement (suspended sentence of imprisonment)” concluded under case number 2026부해349.
Decision date: 2026-10-08 · Decision body: Jeonbuk Regional Labor Relations Commission · Case No.: 2026부해349
Key issue summary:
A. Whether automatic retirement constitutes a dismissal
The employer’s disposition placing a worker on automatic retirement on the ground that an automatic retirement cause under the work rules had arisen constitutes a dismissal subject to the statutory restrictions under the Labor Standards Act.
1. Legal Implications
Ⅰ. Case Overview
This unfair dismissal case was handled by the Jeonbuk Regional Labor Relations Commission and concerned an employer who, relying on an automatic retirement clause in its work rules, imposed automatic retirement on a worker who had been sentenced to imprisonment or a heavier punishment. While the Commission acknowledged the legitimacy of the automatic retirement cause itself, it found the automatic retirement in this case to be an unfair dismissal on the ground that the employer failed to comply with procedures such as written notice of dismissal.
The issue in this case is whether “automatic retirement” of a worker whose criminal sentence has become final constitutes a dismissal under the Labor Standards Act, and whether both the substantive grounds for automatic retirement and the dismissal procedures are lawful.
Ⅱ. Summary of Issues
The issues in this case are, first, whether automatic retirement carried out pursuant to work rules constitutes a dismissal subject to the restrictions of the Labor Standards Act, rather than an automatic termination of the employment relationship. Second, whether a provision that defines as an automatic retirement cause “a person who has been sentenced to imprisonment or a heavier punishment and for whom two years have not elapsed from the date the period of suspension of execution has expired” constitutes a just cause for dismissal that is reasonable under social norms. Third, whether, even where the cause for automatic retirement is substantively justified, the disposition may still be viewed as an unfair dismissal if there is a procedural defect, such as failure to provide written notice of the grounds and timing of dismissal.
Ⅲ. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Findings
The panel in this case held that, even if an employer designates certain grounds as causes for automatic retirement in its work rules and provides procedures different from those for ordinary dismissal, where such grounds cannot readily be regarded as causes of automatic termination such as death, mandatory retirement age, or expiration of a fixed-term contract, they fall within the scope of dismissal subject to the restrictions under Article 23 of the Labor Standards Act.
The panel further held that the cause for automatic retirement arose upon the worker’s conviction becoming final, and that the mere fact that the period of suspension of execution and the period of disqualification had elapsed does not extinguish a cause for automatic retirement that has already arisen. It also found that a provision defining as an automatic retirement cause “a person who has been sentenced to imprisonment or a heavier punishment and for whom two years have not elapsed from the date the period of suspension of execution has expired” is reasonable under social norms.
In addition, the panel held that, since disposition by way of removal from office ex officio or automatic retirement also constitutes dismissal, the obligation of written notice under Article 27 of the Labor Standards Act applies. Where an employer dismisses a worker without providing written notice specifying the timing and grounds for dismissal, the dismissal does not take effect. In this case, no such written notice was given. As a result, the panel found that the dismissal in this case was unfair due to procedural defects.
The dismissal in this case was found to be unfair due to procedural defects.
Ⅳ. Practical Points (From the Employee’s Perspective)
From the employee’s perspective, even if the employer labels the measure as “automatic retirement” or “removal from office ex officio,” if in substance it is a unilateral termination of the employment relationship by the employer, it will be treated as a dismissal under the Labor Standards Act and must satisfy both just cause and lawful procedures. In particular, even where a worker has received a sentence of imprisonment or a suspended sentence in a criminal case, it is important to carefully review the content of the automatic retirement clause in the work rules, the relationship between the offense and the job, the impact on the company, and whether written notice of dismissal was provided, in order to assess the possibility of filing for relief from unfair dismissal.
Ⅴ. Practical Points (From the Employer’s Perspective)
From the employer’s side, it is possible to make use of the fact that, in principle, it is respected—within the bounds of what is reasonable under social norms—to designate as an automatic retirement cause matters that have a serious impact on qualifications or creditworthiness, such as “being sentenced to imprisonment or a heavier punishment.” However, so long as automatic retirement or removal from office ex officio constitutes dismissal, the employer must deliver to the worker a written document specifying the grounds and timing of dismissal, and the dismissal only takes effect upon such delivery. Accordingly, in actual HR practice, employers should operate a procedural checklist equivalent to that used for disciplinary dismissal.
Furthermore, as with economic dismissals such as collective redundancies, employers should avoid drafting automatic retirement causes in personnel regulations or work rules with an excessively broad scope. They should carefully review, on a case-by-case basis, the content of the criminal case, its relation to the worker’s duties, and its impact on corporate order, and exercise caution so that their discretion is not deemed abused.
2. Matters Decided
A. Case Overview and Procedural History
This is a case in which automatic retirement was held to constitute a dismissal subject to the restrictions of the Labor Standards Act, and in which the cause for automatic retirement was found to be justified, but the disposition was nevertheless found to be unfair due to procedural defects.
3. Summary of Decision
A. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Findings
a. Whether automatic retirement constitutes dismissal
Where an employer imposes automatic retirement on a worker on the ground that an automatic retirement cause has arisen, such disposition constitutes a dismissal subject to the statutory restrictions under the Labor Standards Act.
b. Whether the cause for automatic retirement is justified
The cause for automatic retirement arose upon the worker’s conviction becoming final, and the mere fact that the period of suspension of execution and the period of disqualification have elapsed does not extinguish a cause for automatic retirement that has already arisen. Since it is reasonable under social norms for the employer to define as an automatic retirement cause “a person who has been sentenced to imprisonment or a heavier punishment and for whom two years have not elapsed from the date the period of suspension of execution has expired,” the cause for automatic retirement is justified.
c. Whether the automatic retirement procedures were lawful
Because the employer did not provide written notice of the timing of dismissal when dismissing the worker, the automatic retirement is unfair due to procedural defects.
[See More Related Decisions]
- “Unfair Dismissal Decision on ‘Relief Interest·Refusal to Rehire (Post-Retirement Fixed-Term Employment)’”
- “Unfair Dismissal Decision on ‘Failure to Meet Requirements for Redundancy Dismissal (Workout Company)’”
- “Unfair Dismissal Decision on ‘Excessive Disciplinary Measure (Negligent Supervision and Management)’”
[Tags]
Unfair dismissal, automatic retirement (suspended sentence of imprisonment), disciplinary dismissal, others, Labor Law Firm Law&, large labor law firm, Samseong-dong labor law firm, Samseong Station labor law firm, Gangnam labor law firm
※ This article is part of Labor Law Firm Law&’s “Unfair Dismissal Decisions” series.
※ The previous article, “Unfair Dismissal Decision on ‘Right to Terminate Probationary Employment (Request for Physical Contact with Colleague)’,” can be viewed in a new window.
※ The list of decisions related to automatic retirement (suspended sentence of imprisonment) can be viewed together at “List of Decisions Related to Automatic Retirement (Suspended Sentence of Imprisonment).”
※ Korean version of this case: Korean article
