Corporate trends / Performance record
Unfair Dismissal Decision on “Employee Status (Full-Time Work by Freelancer)” (Unfair Dismissal 843)
- Date2026/11/20 00:00
- Read 3
[Case Information]
This case is an unfair dismissal decision concluded under case number 2026부해951, in which “employee status (full‑time work by freelancer)” was the key issue.
Decision date: 2026‑10‑08 · Decision body: Incheon Regional Labor Relations Commission · Case No.: 2026부해951
Key issue summary:
A. Whether the worker qualifies as an “employee” under the Labor Standards Act.
The worker had entered into a freelancer contract but continued to perform the same duties as when previously employed as an employee, working full‑time at fixed hours and in a fixed workplace, and was subject to the principal contractor’s work instructions and leave management.
1. Legal Implications
Ⅰ. Case Overview
This case concerns a full‑time worker who, while formally under a freelancer contract, received a notice of termination from the principal contractor and filed an application for remedy for unfair dismissal, which was adjudicated by the Incheon Regional Labor Relations Commission. The Commission comprehensively examined whether the worker qualified as an employee under the Labor Standards Act, whether the company was a business with five or more regular employees, and whether the dismissal in question was justified.
The worker requested monetary compensation instead of reinstatement to the original position, and the Commission, premising its decision on a finding of unfair dismissal, granted a monetary compensation order.
Ⅱ. Summary of Issues
The issues in this case are: “Whether a full‑time worker who has entered into a freelancer contract qualifies as an employee under the Labor Standards Act; whether the dismissal carried out at a business which, including that worker, has five or more regular employees, was based on just cause and followed due process; and, if the dismissal is found to be unfair, how a monetary compensation order should be granted.”
Ⅲ. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Findings
The panel in this case found that the worker continuously performed the same duties as former employees at the time and place designated by the employer; that the worker was under the principal contractor’s specific work instructions and personnel control, including leave management, and received a fixed monthly wage and work equipment; and that, in practice, concurrent employment or delegation of the work to a third party was difficult, resulting in strong exclusivity toward the employer.
In light of these circumstances, the panel held that, although the worker had formally entered into a freelancer contract, in substance the worker provided labor in a subordinate relationship for the purpose of wages and therefore qualified as an employee under the Labor Standards Act. It further held that, considering that other freelancers assigned to public‑sector projects were also bound by working hours and workplace requirements, those freelancers should be included in calculating the number of regular employees, and that, on this basis, the company constituted a business with five or more regular employees subject to the Labor Standards Act.
Furthermore, the panel determined that relying on unauthorized departure from the worksite and refusal to return as grounds for contract termination was inconsistent with the autonomy in work performance originally contemplated in the freelancer service contract. Taking into account that medical certificates and other evidence substantiated health‑related reasons for the worker’s inability to return immediately, and that the principal contractor blocked further contact despite the worker’s expressed intention to return after recovery, the panel found that it was difficult to attribute fault to the worker sufficient to justify the dismissal. Accordingly, it held that the dismissal in this case constituted unfair dismissal.
Given that the worker explicitly requested monetary compensation in lieu of reinstatement and considering the amount of wages lost between the date of dismissal and the date of the decision, the panel found it appropriate to order payment of KRW 11,700,000 by way of monetary compensation.
Ⅳ. Practical Points (From the Worker’s Perspective)
Even if you are under a freelancer or service contract, you may still be recognized as an employee under the Labor Standards Act if you work full‑time at fixed hours and in a fixed workplace, are subject to the employer’s direction and supervision and leave management, and receive a fixed wage. The mere facts that you own your own work equipment or are not covered by the four major social insurances do not, by themselves, negate employee status. It is therefore important to actively explain the actual working conditions to the Labor Relations Commission.
If there is a possibility that your case will be found to involve unfair dismissal and you consider reinstatement to be unrealistic, you should also consider, within the Labor Relations Commission procedure, applying for a monetary compensation order to seek compensation that includes the equivalent of lost wages and an element akin to consolation money.
Ⅴ. Practical Points (From the Employer/Company’s Perspective)
Even where the formal arrangement is that of a freelancer, service, or consignment contract, if in reality the worker is treated in the same way as a full‑time employee—being assigned fixed working hours and a fixed workplace, placed under specific direction and supervision, and paid a fixed wage—there is a very high risk that the worker will be recognized as an employee for purposes of determining employee status and the number of regular employees. Employers cannot avoid the application of the Labor Standards Act based solely on the formal title of the contract, and should therefore realign the method of work performance, remuneration system, and command‑and‑control structure to reflect the actual circumstances.
Moreover, if an employer unilaterally blocks contact or responds with dismissal in cases of absence or delayed return due to health reasons, despite the existence of objective materials such as medical certificates, there is a high likelihood that the dismissal will be found to be unfair. When considering disciplinary action or contract termination, employers should secure procedural fairness by confirming the facts, providing an opportunity for explanation, issuing warnings, and considering alternative measures, and, where necessary, seek advice from a specialized institution such as Labor Law Firm Law& to prevent disputes.
This decision of the Incheon Regional Labor Relations Commission is a case that simultaneously illustrates the criteria for recognizing employee status in the context of unfair dismissal, the requirement of having five or more regular employees, and the use of the monetary compensation order system. Businesses that operate with similar freelancer structures should actively refer to this case when reviewing their HR and labor‑management risk.
2. Matters Decided
A. Case Overview and Procedural History
This is a case in which the Commission held that the worker qualified as an employee under the Labor Standards Act; that the company was a business with five or more regular employees; and that the dismissal imposed by the employer lacked just cause and therefore constituted unfair dismissal.
3. Summary of Decision
A. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Findings
a. Whether the worker qualifies as an employee under the Labor Standards Act
The worker entered into a freelancer contract but continued to perform the same duties as when previously employed as an employee, working full‑time at fixed hours and in a fixed workplace, and was subject to the principal contractor’s work instructions and leave management. The worker continuously performed the employer’s contracted work, received a fixed monthly remuneration, and was provided with work equipment, and in practice could not easily engage in concurrent employment or delegate the work to a third party. Accordingly, the worker qualifies as an employee under the Labor Standards Act.
b. Whether the company has five or more regular employees
In light of the company’s project status and other circumstances, freelancers performing work for public institutions and similar clients appear to be bound by working hours and workplace requirements in the same way as the worker. If freelancers working under the same conditions as the worker are included in the number of regular employees, the company constitutes a business with five or more regular employees.
c. Whether the dismissal was justified (in terms of cause and procedure)
Using unauthorized departure from the worksite and refusal to return as grounds for contract termination conflicts with the provisions of the freelancer service contract, which guaranteed autonomy in work performance. In addition, the worker’s inability to return immediately is recognized as being due to health reasons supported by medical certificates and other evidence, and the principal contractor blocked contact even after the worker expressed an intention to return once health had improved. Therefore, there is no fault attributable to the worker sufficient to justify the dismissal, and the dismissal constitutes unfair dismissal.
d. Whether to grant the application for a monetary compensation order
Since the worker seeks monetary compensation in lieu of reinstatement, it is appropriate to grant this request and order payment of KRW 11,700,000 (eleven million seven hundred thousand won) as monetary compensation.
[See More Related Decisions]
- “Unfair Dismissal Decision on ‘Relief Interest · Refusal to Rehire (Post‑Retirement Fixed‑Term Employment)’”
- “Unfair Dismissal Decision on ‘Automatic Retirement (Suspended Sentence of Imprisonment)’” – Decision date: 2026‑10‑08
- “Unfair Dismissal Decision on ‘Disciplinary Measure Level (Participation in Services for Another Institution)’”
[Tags]
Unfair dismissal, employee status (full‑time work by freelancer), unauthorized absence, others, Labor Law Firm Law&, large labor law firm, Samseong‑dong labor law firm, Samseong Station labor law firm, Gangnam labor law firm
※ This article is part of the “Unfair Dismissal Decisions” series by Labor Law Firm Law&.
※ You can view the previous article, “Unfair Dismissal Decision on ‘Automatic Retirement (Suspended Sentence of Imprisonment)’,” in a new window.
※ You can also view the list of decisions related to employee status (full‑time work by freelancer) at “List of Decisions Related to Employee Status (Full‑Time Work by Freelancer).”
※ Korean version of this case: Korean article
