Labor law firm Law&

Corporate performance /
Consultation inquiry

    Corporate trends / Performance record

    ‘Standing to Sue (In‑House Partner Company Delivery Driver)’ Unfair Dismissal Decision (Unfair Dismissal 844)
    • Date2026/11/20 00:00
    • Read 3
    [Case Information] This case is an unfair dismissal decision on the issue of “standing to sue (in‑house partner company delivery driver),” concluded under case number 2026BuHae3062. Decision date: 2026-10-08 · Decision body: Gyeonggi Regional Labor Relations Commission · Case No.: 2026BuHae3062 Summary of key issue: The worker in this case appears to have performed delivery work to Kia Motors for “○○ Logistics,” which had entered into a goods transportation contract with “○○ Company,” a supplier of automotive parts to the employer in this case. As there is no objective evidence on the basis of which the status of employer can be recognized for the employer in this case, Kia Motors Corporation, the application for remedy was dismissed on the ground that it was filed against an employer lacking standing to be a party. 1. Legal Implications Ⅰ. Case Overview This case concerns a delivery/transport worker who claimed unfair dismissal and filed an application for remedy with the Labor Relations Commission against Kia Motors. The worker had been performing delivery work to Kia Motors’ plant through “○○ Logistics,” which had entered into a goods transportation contract with “○○ Company,” a supplier of automotive parts to Kia Motors. The Gyeonggi Regional Labor Relations Commission first determined whether the respondent was a party to an employment contract, that is, whether it had standing to be sued, and then dismissed the application for remedy. Ⅱ. Summary of Issues The issue in this case is whether a transport worker who carried out delivery work to Kia Motors’ plant through an in‑house partner/logistics company can be recognized as having sufficient grounds to treat the principal company, Kia Motors, as an employer with standing to be sued in an unfair dismissal remedy proceeding. Ⅲ. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Reasoning The panel in this case found that the worker had not entered into a direct employment contract with Kia Motors, but had instead performed delivery work to Kia Motors for “○○ Logistics,” which had entered into a goods transportation contract with “○○ Company,” a supplier of parts. It further found that there was no objective evidence indicating that Kia Motors exercised employer authority over this worker, such as personnel or disciplinary authority, direct payment of wages, or enrollment in the four major social insurances, nor any other objective circumstances showing direction, supervision, or personnel management as an employer. In addition, in light of the relevant case law, for a principal company to be recognized as an employer based on the substantive existence of a relationship of subordination, a substantial level of direct direction and supervision and involvement in determining working conditions must be proven. No such circumstances were revealed in this case. Accordingly, the Commission held that it was difficult to recognize Kia Motors Corporation, the employer in this case, as an employer under the Labor Standards Act and, ultimately, that Kia Motors lacked standing to be sued as the respondent in the unfair dismissal remedy application. Therefore, the Commission determined that, irrespective of whether the dismissal disposition itself existed or was valid, the application for remedy should be dismissed on the ground that it had been filed against a company lacking standing to be a party. Ⅳ. Practical Points (From the Worker’s Perspective) From the worker’s perspective, it is essential first to identify clearly with whom the employment contract was actually concluded, who pays wages, and who is responsible for enrollment in the four major social insurances and exercises personnel and disciplinary authority. Even if the principal company directs work on site, in structures where the contractual employer and the de facto employer (principal company) differ, there is a high risk of dismissal of a remedy application on the ground of lack of standing to sue, as in this case, if the respondent is incorrectly designated in the Labor Relations Commission proceeding. When seeking to challenge an unfair dismissal in similar indirect employment or in‑house partner company structures, it is advisable to consult in advance with experts such as Labor Law Firm Law& to formulate a strategy, including whether the principal company’s status as employer can be contested under case law on implied employment contracts or worker dispatch relationships. Ⅴ. Practical Points (From the Employer/Company’s Perspective) From the principal company’s perspective, when utilizing in‑house partner companies, logistics companies, or contracting/outsourcing structures, it must always be borne in mind that excessive direction and supervision, performance evaluation, or involvement in discipline with respect to personnel belonging to partner companies on site may give rise to a risk that a worker dispatch relationship or implied employment contract will be recognized. Conversely, as in this case, where an independent business operator (○○ Logistics/○○ Company) is exclusively responsible for personnel and labor management, wage payment, and enrollment in the four major social insurances, and the principal company’s role is limited under the contract to indirect management such as placing orders and inspecting deliveries, there is a high likelihood that employer status and standing to be sued will be denied by the Labor Relations Commission. Accordingly, it is important to systematically maintain contracts, tax and payroll records, organizational charts, and similar documents that can substantiate this substantive structure. This decision clearly illustrates how crucial it is in unfair dismissal remedy procedures to identify accurately “who is the true employer and party.” Both workers and companies should consider, with the assistance of specialized institutions such as Labor Law Firm Law&, conducting a prior review of issues relating to employer status and standing to sue. 2. Matters Decided a. Case Overview and Procedural History A case in which it was held that the respondent had no standing to be a party because it was not a party to the employment contract. 3. Gist of the Decision a. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Reasoning The worker in this case appears to have performed delivery work to Kia Motors for “○○ Logistics,” which had entered into a goods transportation contract with “○○ Company,” a supplier of automotive parts to the employer in this case. As there is no objective evidence on the basis of which the status of employer can be recognized for the employer in this case, Kia Motors Corporation, the application for remedy filed against this employer, which lacks standing to be a party, is to be dismissed. [See More Related Decisions] - “Unfair Dismissal Decision on Worker Status (Full‑Time Work by Freelancer)” – Decision date: 2026-10-08 - “Unfair Dismissal Decision on Expectation of Succession of Employment (Competitive Bidding for Logistics Center)” - “Unfair Dismissal Decision on Appropriateness of Disciplinary Measure (Participation in Services for Another Institution)” [Tags] Unfair dismissal, standing to sue (in‑house partner company delivery driver), others, Labor Law Firm Law&, large labor law firm, Samseong‑dong labor law firm, Samseong Station labor law firm, Gangnam labor law firm ※ This article is part of the “Unfair Dismissal Decisions” series by Labor Law Firm Law&. ※ The previous article, “Unfair Dismissal Decision on Worker Status (Full‑Time Work by Freelancer),” can be viewed in a new window. ※ A list of decisions related to standing to sue (in‑house partner company delivery driver) can be viewed together under “List of Decisions Related to Standing to Sue (In‑House Partner Company Delivery Driver).” ※ Korean version of this case: Korean article
    ⚙