Labor law firm Law&

Corporate performance /
Consultation inquiry

    Corporate trends / Performance record

    Unfair Dismissal Decision on “Disciplinary Severity (Supervisor in Workplace Sexual Harassment Case)” (Unfair Dismissal 845)
    • Date2026/11/21 00:00
    • Read 3
    [Case Information] This case is a decision on the issue of “disciplinary severity (supervisor in workplace sexual harassment case),” concluded under case number 2026부해307. Decision date: 2026-10-07 · Decision body: Ulsan Regional Labor Relations Commission · Case No.: 2026부해307 Key issue summary: A. Existence of grounds for discipline The worker argued, in substance, that his conduct merely expressed friendliness toward the victim or was intended to lighten her mood, that it was not coercive, and therefore did not constitute workplace sexual harassment and could not properly serve as grounds for discipline. However, in the interview investigation, the victim consistently stated that she had been subjected to ongoing sexual harassment despite her expressed refusal, and the company’s rules of employment provide that “sexually offensive remarks or conduct, demands, physical contact, etc. constituting sexual harassment…” are grounds for discipline... 1. Legal Implications Ⅰ. Case Overview In this case, the worker filed an application for relief from unfair dismissal against a disciplinary measure imposed for workplace sexual harassment. The Ulsan Regional Labor Relations Commission heard the matter as an unfair dismissal case. The worker asserted that his words and conduct were no more than an expression of friendliness toward the victim, were not coercive, and therefore could not constitute grounds for discipline, and that the level of discipline imposed was excessive. The Labor Relations Commission did not accept these arguments. Ⅱ. Summary of Issues The issues in this case are whether, notwithstanding the worker’s assertion that his sexually related remarks and conduct in the workplace were merely expressions of friendliness or jokes, they nevertheless constitute workplace sexual harassment falling under the grounds for discipline set out in the rules of employment, and whether the level of discipline imposed by the company for the supervisor’s repeated sexual harassment was manifestly unreasonable in light of social norms. Ⅲ. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Findings The panel in this case found that there was no difficulty in treating the misconduct at issue as grounds for discipline, given that: the victim consistently stated during the interview process that she had been subjected to ongoing sexual harassment despite her expressed refusal; the company’s rules of employment expressly define sexual remarks, physical contact, and similar conduct as grounds for discipline; and the worker held a position of hierarchical superiority over the victim. The panel further held that it was difficult to regard the disciplinary measure as a manifestly unreasonable exercise of discretion that had lost its validity in light of social norms, considering that: as a manager, the worker was in a position that required a high level of ethical awareness and exemplary conduct and was responsible for supervising the misconduct of subordinates; the verbal and physical sexual conduct toward the victim continued on a non‑isolated, ongoing, and repeated basis over approximately nine months; the worker had a prior disciplinary record of demotion, which is a factor aggravating disciplinary severity under the disciplinary severity decision table; and, given that the workplace is characterized by a high proportion of female workers and that most managers are male, the eradication of sexual harassment is a particularly important obligation of the employer. In addition, the panel found no particular defect in the disciplinary procedure, noting that the company convened a disciplinary committee pursuant to the rules of employment, that the worker appeared before the committee and was given an opportunity to explain himself, and that the disciplinary decision was notified to the worker. Ⅳ. Practical Points (From the Worker’s Perspective) From the worker’s perspective, it must be borne in mind that even where one subjectively believes that one is merely “creating a friendly atmosphere” or “joking around,” repeated sexual remarks or conduct made despite the other party’s express or implied refusal may be recognized as workplace sexual harassment, thereby justifying severe disciplinary measures. This is particularly so for those in supervisory or managerial positions, who are subject to higher ethical obligations. Long‑term, repeated conduct and prior disciplinary history operate as aggravating factors in determining disciplinary severity. Accordingly, it is necessary to maintain strict personal standards regarding sexual remarks and conduct, even at company dinners or informal gatherings. Ⅴ. Practical Points (From the Employer/Company Perspective) From the employer’s perspective, it is important to set out grounds for discipline relating to sexual harassment in concrete terms in the rules of employment, and, when an incident actually occurs, to carefully secure the victim’s statements and circumstantial evidence and to conduct the disciplinary process strictly through a disciplinary committee. In organizations with a high proportion of female workers or a clearly defined hierarchy, ongoing sexual harassment prevention training and recurrence‑prevention measures should be implemented on a continuous basis. At the same time, the personnel and labor management system should be structured on the premise that firm disciplinary measures within the scope of the employer’s discretion can be justified in cases of long‑term, repeated sexual harassment and misconduct by managers. 2. Matters Decided A. Case Overview and Procedural History This is a case in which the application for relief was dismissed on the grounds that the disciplinary reasons, including workplace sexual harassment, were recognized, the level of discipline was appropriate, and there were no procedural defects in the disciplinary process. 3. Gist of the Decision A. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Findings A. Existence of Grounds for Discipline The worker argued, in substance, that his conduct merely expressed friendliness toward the victim or was intended to lighten her mood, that it was not coercive, and therefore did not constitute workplace sexual harassment and could not properly serve as grounds for discipline. However, taking into account the following: the victim, during the interview investigation, stated that she had been subjected to ongoing sexual harassment despite her expressed refusal; the company’s rules of employment explicitly specify “cases of sexual harassment such as sexually offensive remarks or conduct, demands, physical contact, etc.” as grounds for discipline; and the worker appears to have been in a position of hierarchical superiority over the victim; the panel finds that there is no significant difficulty in treating the worker’s misconduct as grounds for discipline. B. Appropriateness of the Level of Discipline The panel notes that the worker was in a position that required him to demonstrate higher ethical awareness and exemplary conduct and, indeed, to supervise and admonish the misconduct of subordinates within his department; that he held a superior position over the victim in the workplace; that over a long period of approximately nine months, inappropriate verbal and physical sexual conduct toward the victim did not occur on a one‑off basis but continued in an ongoing and repeated manner; that the company’s rules of employment specify inappropriate sexual remarks and conduct as grounds for discipline; that, under the disciplinary severity decision table, the worker had a prior disciplinary record of demotion, which is an aggravating factor; that the eradication of sexual harassment in the workplace is a primary obligation of the employer, regardless of whether the victim remains employed; and that the characteristics of the workplace—approximately 60% of the workforce being female and most managers being male—must be taken into account. Considering all of these factors comprehensively, the panel finds it difficult to conclude that the disciplinary measure has so clearly lost its validity as to constitute an abuse of discretion. C. Legality of the Disciplinary Procedure The worker did not raise any particular objection regarding the legality of the disciplinary procedure. The company convened a disciplinary committee pursuant to the rules of employment and other internal regulations, and the worker appeared before that committee and presented his explanation. It is confirmed that the disciplinary committee notified the worker of the disciplinary decision. Accordingly, the panel finds that there were no procedural defects in the disciplinary process. [See More Related Decisions] - “Unfair Dismissal Decision on ‘Disciplinary Severity (Participation in Services for Another Institution)’” - “Unfair Dismissal Decision on ‘Excessive Disciplinary Severity (Negligent Management/Supervision)’” - “Unfair Dismissal Decision on ‘Expectation of Employment Succession (Competitive Bidding for Logistics Center)’” [Tags] Unfair dismissal, disciplinary severity (supervisor in workplace sexual harassment case), disciplinary dismissal, workplace harassment, Labor Law Firm Law&, large labor law firm, Samseong‑dong labor law firm, Samseong Station labor law firm, Gangnam labor law firm ※ This article is part of the “Unfair Dismissal Decisions” series by Labor Law Firm Law&. ※ The previous article, “Unfair Dismissal Decision on ‘Standing to Sue (In‑house Partner Company Delivery Driver)’,” can be viewed in a new window. ※ The list of decisions related to disciplinary severity (supervisor in workplace sexual harassment case) can be viewed together in the “List of Decisions on Disciplinary Severity (Supervisor in Workplace Sexual Harassment Case).” ※ Korean version of this case: Korean article
    ⚙