Labor law firm Law&

Corporate performance /
Consultation inquiry

    Corporate trends / Performance record

    Case on Unfair Dismissal Relating to “Existence of a Hiring Decision (Email Notice of Final Interview Pass)” (Unfair Dismissal 846)
    • Date2026/11/21 00:00
    • Read 3
    [Case Information] This case is a decision concluded under case number 2026부해190 on the issue of “existence of a hiring decision (email notice of final interview pass).” Decision date: 2026-10-07 · Decision body: Jeju Regional Labor Relations Commission · Case No.: 2026부해190 Key issue summary: The job posting expressly distinguished between the interview stage, the stage for negotiating employment conditions (compensation, start date), and the stage of confirming final acceptance, and the worker was aware of this. 1. Legal Implications Ⅰ. Case Overview This application for relief from unfair dismissal was handled by the Jeju Regional Labor Relations Commission. The worker filed an application with the Labor Relations Commission against the employer company, claiming unfair dismissal on the ground that the employer had cancelled a hiring decision (hiring “naejung”). In this decision summary prepared by Labor Law Firm Law&, we focus on the reasoning for finding that an employment contract had not in fact been formed, even though the worker had received an email notifying them that they had “passed the final interview” and had been expecting to join the company. The employer conducted the recruitment process in accordance with the job posting and notified the worker that they had passed the interview. However, the employer did not finalize the hiring while negotiations on compensation and the start date remained incomplete, and did not issue an employment contract or a formal notice of acceptance. The worker claimed that this constituted a unilateral cancellation after a hiring decision had been made, i.e., an unfair dismissal, and applied to the Labor Relations Commission for relief. Ⅱ. Issues The issue in this case was whether, in circumstances where the worker had been notified of passing the interview and received congratulatory remarks along with a request to discuss compensation, the employer’s definite intent to hire had been expressed externally and objectively, and further, whether a hiring decision (hiring “naejung”) had been formed so as to constitute a “dismissal” (unfair dismissal) under the Labor Standards Act. Ⅲ. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Reasoning The decision panel noted that the job posting specified the interview stage, the stage for negotiating compensation and start date, and the stage of confirming final acceptance as separate steps; that the worker was aware of this; and that although the employer’s email used the expression “final interview pass” and included congratulatory remarks, it also repeatedly informed the worker that “final acceptance will be made after negotiations on compensation and start date.” Taking into account that the essential terms of the employment contract, such as annual salary and other specific conditions, had neither been presented nor agreed upon; that the start date had not been fixed; that no written document such as an employment contract or notice of acceptance had been prepared or delivered; that the request for materials for compensation negotiations and for the worker’s available start dates was no more than a step for negotiations; and that it was difficult to regard congratulatory remarks from the line manager, who did not have authority to finalize hiring, or the worker’s submission of a resignation letter to their former employer, as an external and objective manifestation of the employer’s definite intent to hire, The Commission concluded that no hiring decision—i.e., no express or implied employment contract—had been formed between the parties. Accordingly, the employer’s refusal to hire did not constitute a dismissal under the Labor Standards Act, and the application for relief from unfair dismissal could not be upheld. Ⅳ. Practical Points (From the Worker’s Perspective) From the worker’s perspective, it is important to note that a simple notice of “final interview pass” or congratulatory remarks made verbally or by phone do not, by themselves, immediately establish a hiring decision. The likelihood that a hiring decision will be recognized is much higher where the parties have agreed on specific working conditions such as annual salary, working hours, job duties, and start date, and where there is material in which the company has clearly and objectively expressed final acceptance or a confirmed hiring decision (such as a notice of acceptance or an employment contract). In particular, before making significant decisions such as resigning from a current job, workers should obtain clear confirmation by email, text message, or in writing regarding “whether final acceptance and a confirmed hiring decision have been made” and “the key working conditions.” In addition, there is a strong trend in case law of placing the burden of proof regarding the formation of a hiring decision on the worker before the Labor Relations Commission or the courts, so it is important to develop the habit of securing and retaining relevant materials oneself. Ⅴ. Practical Points (From the Employer/Company Perspective) From the company’s perspective, it is advisable to clearly distinguish and explain the stages of “interview pass, compensation negotiations, and final hiring decision” in job postings and throughout the recruitment process, and to clarify the meaning of any use of the term “final pass” in written communications such as email or messenger (e.g., interview pass vs. confirmed hiring) to avoid confusion. In particular, before essential working conditions such as annual salary and start date are finalized, the company should refrain from using expressions that may be misunderstood as indicating that hiring has already been decided, and should establish internal guidelines to prevent line departments that lack authority to finalize hiring from independently offering congratulations or using definitive language. Furthermore, once a hiring decision has been formed and is then withdrawn, this may constitute a dismissal under the Labor Standards Act, raising issues of just cause and the obligation to give written notice. Accordingly, HR and legal departments should, in advance, determine when and in what form final notices of acceptance (hiring decisions) will be given, and how to draft wording used at earlier stages of the process. 2. Matters Decided a. Case Overview and Procedural History This is a case in which the Commission held that no hiring decision had been formed, on the grounds that although the employer notified the worker that they had passed the interview and expressly stated that final acceptance would be made after negotiations on compensation and start date, the parties had not presented or agreed on wages and other working conditions. 3. Summary of Decision a. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Reasoning The job posting expressly distinguished between the interview stage, the stage for negotiating employment conditions (compensation, start date), and the stage of confirming final acceptance, and the worker was aware of this. In the email sent by the employer, there were expressions such as “final interview pass” and congratulations, but in the same email the employer clearly stated that final acceptance would be made after negotiations on compensation and start date, and thereafter repeatedly notified the worker that they would be informed of final acceptance once compensation negotiations were complete. Although the job posting did not specify salary, the employer never presented specific compensation terms such as annual salary, the start date was not fixed, and no employment contract or notice of acceptance was prepared or delivered. The request for materials for compensation negotiations and for a reply on possible start dates was only for the purpose of calculating compensation and negotiating the start date. There was no evidence that the line manager, who offered congratulations during a phone call, had exercised or had been delegated authority to finalize hiring. Nor could the employer’s definite intent to hire be regarded as having been clearly expressed externally and objectively merely because the worker expected to join the company and submitted a resignation letter to their former employer. Therefore, it could not be found that a hiring decision had been formed between the parties. [See More Related Decisions] - “‘Non-Formation of Hiring Decision (Absence of Offer Letter)’ Related Unfair Dismissal Decision” – Decision date: - · Case No.: Original decision upheld - “‘Business Necessity (Reassignment of Cleaning Staff)’ Related Unfair Dismissal Decision” - “‘Interest in Relief · Refusal to Rehire (Post-Retirement Fixed-Term Employee)’ Related Unfair Dismissal Decision” [Tags] Unfair dismissal, existence of hiring decision (email notice of final interview pass), others, Labor Law Firm Law&, large labor law firm, Samseong-dong labor law firm, Samseong Station labor law firm, Gangnam labor law firm ※ This article is part of the “Unfair Dismissal Decisions” series by Labor Law Firm Law&. ※ You can view the previous article, “‘Disciplinary Severity (Supervisor in Workplace Sexual Harassment Case)’ Related Unfair Dismissal Decision,” in a new window. ※ A list of decisions related to existence of a hiring decision (email notice of final interview pass) can be found in the “List of Decisions Related to Existence of Hiring Decision (Email Notice of Final Interview Pass).” ※ Korean version of this case: Korean article
    ⚙