Labor law firm Law&

Corporate performance /
Consultation inquiry

    Corporate trends / Performance record

    Unfair Dismissal Precedent on “Excessive Disciplinary Severity (Posting of Resident Notice)” (Unfair Dismissal 847)
    • Date2026/11/21 00:00
    • Read 3
    [Case Information] This case is a precedent concluded under case number 2026부해176, concerning the issue of “excessive disciplinary severity (posting of resident notice).” Decision date: 2026-10-07 · Decision body: Jeju Regional Labor Relations Commission · Case No.: 2026부해176 Key issue summary: A. Legitimacy of the grounds for discipline The employer’s allegations of forgery and alteration of the employment contract, embezzlement of public funds and breach of duty, violation of the Personal Information Protection Act, violation of the Protection of Communications Secrets Act, and disruption of the organization are difficult to deem sufficiently proven based solely on the materials submitted. 1. Legal Implications Ⅰ. Case Overview This unfair dismissal case arose at a workplace that appears to be a social welfare/residential facility, where a worker was subjected to disciplinary dismissal for posting a notice to residents and for showing a statement of damage to a superior, among other acts, and then applied to the Labor Relations Commission for relief. The Jeju Regional Labor Relations Commission found that a substantial portion of the alleged grounds for discipline was not sufficiently proven, but that certain inappropriate handling of duties did constitute grounds for discipline. The Commission focused its review on whether the level of discipline imposed was excessively severe. In similar disciplinary dismissal cases, Labor Law Firm Law& also treats it as a key issue to separately examine the three elements of disciplinary grounds, procedure, and severity. Ⅱ. Summary of Issues The issue in this case is: “In circumstances where some inappropriate handling of duties by the worker is recognized as grounds for discipline, does the employer’s choice of the most severe disciplinary measure—disciplinary dismissal—constitute an abuse of its discretionary power in disciplinary matters due to excessive severity of the sanction?” Ⅲ. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Findings The panel in this case held that the employer’s allegations of serious misconduct—such as forgery and alteration of the employment contract, embezzlement of public funds and breach of duty, violations of the Personal Information Protection Act and the Protection of Communications Secrets Act, and disruption of the organization—were difficult to deem proven based solely on the materials submitted. However, the acts of showing the statement of damage to the facility manager and posting a notice to residents were clearly inappropriate from the perspectives of victim protection and confidentiality, and thus were recognized as grounds for discipline. Nevertheless, considering the nature and degree of these recognized grounds, it was difficult to conclude that the employment relationship had become untenable under social norms, and it appeared that correction would be possible through lighter disciplinary measures such as a reprimand or pay reduction. Accordingly, the Commission held that the dismissal in this case was unfair, as the severity of the disciplinary measure was excessively heavy relative to the grounds for discipline and thus exceeded the bounds of the employer’s discretionary authority in disciplinary matters. It also found that there was no serious defect in the disciplinary procedure sufficient to render the dismissal invalid, given that the worker appeared before the personnel committee and provided explanations regarding the handling of duties, and subsequently received written notice specifying the grounds and effective date of the dismissal after the residents’ representative council resolved to dismiss. Ⅳ. Practical Points (From the Worker’s Perspective) From the worker’s perspective, it should be borne in mind that even if not all of the employer’s allegations of misconduct are accepted, some facts may still be recognized as grounds for discipline. However, even where some grounds for discipline are recognized, the Labor Relations Commission may still rule in favor of the worker in its proportionality assessment of whether the misconduct is serious enough to warrant dismissal, or whether a lighter disciplinary measure would suffice. It is therefore important to provide concrete explanations regarding the actual course of work handling, the scale of any damage, and the possibility of preventing recurrence. In particular, when appearing before a disciplinary committee, the worker should refrain from emotional responses and instead submit organized, objective materials demonstrating efforts to minimize damage, willingness to make corrections going forward, and past work attitude. Ⅴ. Practical Points (From the Employer/Company Perspective) From the employer’s perspective, before deciding on disciplinary dismissal, it is necessary to review step by step: (i) whether each alleged act of misconduct can in fact be proven; (ii) whether it falls squarely within the grounds for discipline set out in the rules of employment; and (iii) whether, under social norms, it is serious enough to require dismissal. In particular, if the employer asserts serious grounds such as embezzlement of public funds, violations of the Personal Information Protection Act, or disruption of the organization but fails to prove them sufficiently, the Labor Relations Commission is likely to base its decision only on minor established grounds and find “excessive severity” in the level of discipline. Accordingly, when determining the level of discipline, employers should comprehensively consider the nature and degree of the misconduct, the actual scale of damage, the characteristics of the position, any prior disciplinary history, and the level of sanctions imposed in similar cases. Where appropriate, employers should consider using stepwise disciplinary measures such as reprimand, pay reduction, or suspension instead of dismissal. 2. Matters Decided A. Case Overview and Procedural History This is a case in which the disciplinary dismissal was found to be unfair on the ground that, although there was no defect in the disciplinary procedure, the severity of the sanction was excessively heavy relative to the recognized grounds for discipline. 3. Gist of the Decision A. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Findings a. Legitimacy of the Grounds for Discipline The employer’s allegations of forgery and alteration of the employment contract, embezzlement of public funds and breach of duty, violation of the Personal Information Protection Act, violation of the Protection of Communications Secrets Act, and disruption of the organization are difficult to deem sufficiently proven based solely on the materials submitted. However, certain inappropriate handling of duties related to protection of the victimized employee and confidentiality—such as showing the statement of damage to the facility manager—and the act of posting a notice to residents are recognized as grounds for discipline. b. Appropriateness of the Level of Discipline Only some of the alleged grounds for discipline are recognized, and it is difficult to view the nature and degree of those grounds as serious enough to warrant dismissal. It also cannot be ruled out that correction would be possible through lighter disciplinary measures such as reprimand or pay reduction. Therefore, dismissal—the most severe disciplinary measure—is deemed excessively heavy relative to the grounds for discipline and thus beyond the bounds of the employer’s discretionary authority in disciplinary matters. c. Legality of the Disciplinary Procedure The worker actually appeared before the personnel committee and provided explanations regarding the handling of duties, and after the residents’ representative council resolved to dismiss, the worker received written notice specifying the concrete grounds and effective date of the dismissal. It is therefore difficult to conclude that there was any defect in the disciplinary procedure sufficient to render the dismissal invalid. [See More Related Precedents] - “Unfair Dismissal Precedent on ‘Disciplinary Severity (Workplace Sexual Harassment by Superior)’” – Decision date: 2026-10-07 - “Unfair Dismissal Precedent on ‘Disciplinary Severity (Participation in Services for Another Institution)’” - “Unfair Dismissal Precedent on ‘Excessive Disciplinary Severity (Negligent Management/Supervision)’” [Tags] Unfair dismissal, excessive disciplinary severity (posting of resident notice), disciplinary dismissal, Labor Law Firm Law&, large labor law firm, Samseong-dong labor law firm, Samseong Station labor law firm, Gangnam labor law firm ※ This article is part of Labor Law Firm Law&’s “Unfair Dismissal Precedents” series. ※ You can view the previous article, “Unfair Dismissal Precedent on ‘Existence of Hiring Commitment (Final Interview Pass Notification by Email)’,” in a new window. ※ The list of precedents related to excessive disciplinary severity (posting of resident notice) can be viewed together under “List of Precedents on Excessive Disciplinary Severity (Posting of Resident Notice).” ※ Korean version of this case: Korean article
    ⚙