Corporate trends / Performance record
‘Refusal to Follow Dispatch Order (Already Confirmed Duty)’ Unfair Dismissal Decision (Unfair Dismissal 848)
- Date2026/11/22 00:00
- Read 3
1. Legal Implications
Ⅰ. Case Overview
This unfair dismissal case concerns a labor commission decision involving a bus driver who expressed an intention not to perform an already confirmed duty, after which the company imposed a three‑day suspension as a disciplinary measure. The employee applied to the Labor Relations Commission for relief, arguing that the disciplinary sanction was excessive and that there were procedural defects, and the Seoul Regional Labor Relations Commission reviewed the legitimacy of the sanction.
Ⅱ. Issues in Dispute
The issue in this case is:
“Where a bus driver, without just cause, states that he or she will not perform an already confirmed duty, thereby disrupting the company’s dispatch order, whether a three‑day suspension imposed on the grounds of violation of the collective agreement and the work rules is justified in terms of the existence of grounds for discipline, the appropriateness of the level of discipline, and the disciplinary procedures.”
Ⅲ. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Decision
The panel in this case found that the employee explicitly expressed an intention not to perform an already confirmed duty, thereby disrupting the company’s dispatch order; that such conduct constitutes a breach of obligations prohibited under the company’s collective agreement and work rules and thus amounts to a valid ground for discipline; and that, given the characteristics of the bus transportation business, it is essential to secure drivers in a stable manner in accordance with the confirmed dispatch plan, and that, where dispatch is refused, the employer bears a significant burden in urgently securing substitute personnel to maintain operations.
Accordingly, it was held that a three‑day suspension could not be regarded as excessively harsh to the extent of constituting an abuse or overreach of the employer’s discretion in imposing discipline. The employee attended the personnel committee and was given an opportunity to explain, and no defects such as violations of the prescribed disciplinary procedures were identified. The disciplinary action in this case was therefore found to be justified.
Ⅳ. Practical Points (From the Employee’s Perspective)
From the employee’s perspective, particularly in transportation businesses such as buses and taxis, it should be borne in mind that the employer’s dispatch order is the most basic work instruction under the employment contract. Even if the employee believes that the dispatch is unfair, unilaterally notifying the employer, without just cause, that “I will not perform the already confirmed duty” may constitute a violation of the collective agreement and work rules and thus a ground for discipline. It is therefore advisable to consult with experts such as Labor Law Firm Law& and make use of objection or consultation procedures.
Ⅴ. Practical Points (From the Employer/Company Perspective)
From the employer’s perspective, it is important to clearly set out, in the collective agreement, work rules, and operating regulations, the necessity and legitimacy of dispatch orders and the step‑by‑step disciplinary measures that may be taken in the event of a refusal to follow a dispatch order. In addition, in disciplinary actions related to refusal to follow dispatch orders, procedural fairness should be strictly ensured—such as by providing an opportunity to appear before the personnel committee and to present explanations—as was done in this labor commission decision.
2. Matters Decided
A. Case Overview and Procedural History
This is a case in which a three‑day suspension imposed on a bus driver who, without just cause, failed to perform an already confirmed duty was held to be justified.
3. Gist of the Decision
A. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Reasoning
a. Existence of Grounds for Discipline
The employee bears responsibility for disrupting the company’s dispatch order by expressing an intention not to perform an already confirmed duty, and this constitutes a violation of the company’s collective agreement and work rules; accordingly, it is recognized as a valid ground for discipline.
b. Appropriateness of the Level of Discipline
In light of (i) the fact that, for a company engaged in the bus transportation business, it is essential to secure drivers in a stable manner and operate in accordance with a confirmed dispatch plan, and (ii) the fact that, if an employee arbitrarily fails to perform an already confirmed duty, the employer must urgently secure substitute personnel and alter the dispatch plan, it is difficult to view the three‑day suspension as an overreach or abuse of the employer’s discretionary authority.
c. Legality of the Disciplinary Procedures
The employee appeared before the personnel committee and presented explanations, and no defects such as violations of the prescribed disciplinary procedures were identified.
[Further Related Decisions]
- ‘Excessive Level of Discipline (Negligent Management/Supervision)’ Unfair Dismissal Decision
- ‘Level of Discipline (Participation in Services for Another Entity)’ Unfair Dismissal Decision
- ‘Relief Interest / Refusal to Rehire (Post‑Retirement Fixed‑Term Employment)’ Unfair Dismissal Decision
[Tags]
Unfair dismissal, refusal to follow dispatch order (already confirmed duty), violation of company policy · failure to comply with work instructions, Labor Law Firm Law&, large labor law firm, Samseong‑dong labor law firm, Samseong Station labor law firm, Gangnam labor law firm
※ This article is part of the “Unfair Dismissal Decisions” series by Labor Law Firm Law&.
※ The previous article, “‘Excessive Level of Discipline (Posting Resident Notice)’ Unfair Dismissal Decision,” can be viewed in a new window.
※ The list of decisions related to refusal to follow dispatch order (already confirmed duty) can be viewed together in the “List of Decisions Related to Refusal to Follow Dispatch Order (Already Confirmed Duty).”
※ Korean version of this case: Korean article
