Labor law firm Law&

Corporate performance /
Consultation inquiry

    Corporate trends / Performance record

    Determination on Unfair Dismissal Relating to “Existence of Dismissal (Payroll Settlement Memo)” (Unfair Dismissal 849)
    • Date2026/11/22 00:00
    • Read 3
    [Case Information] This case is a decision concluded under case number 2026부해2787, concerning the issue of “existence of dismissal (payroll settlement memo).” Decision date: 2026-10-06 · Decision body: Seoul Regional Labor Relations Commission · Case No.: 2026부해2787 Key issue summary: (i) There was no evidence that the employer expressed a definitive intention to dismiss; (ii) the employee did not directly confirm the existence of a dismissal with the representative director; (iii) the request to return the access card came from an employee scheduled to resign, not from the representative director or an executive director; (iv) the employee took the lead in payroll settlement by preparing and submitting a memo specifying working days, pre‑tax and post‑tax salary, 3.3% withholding, and the receiving account; (v) the employer, two days before the meeting, sent text messages to major clients introducing the employee’s successor in charge, and the employee stated that even up to the date of the meeting, while handing over duties, he did not perceive any signs of dismissal; in light of all of this, … 1. Legal Implications Ⅰ. Case Overview This application for remedy for unfair dismissal (부당해고 구제신청 사건) is based on decision 2026부해2787 of the Seoul Regional Labor Relations Commission, in which the employee applied to the Labor Relations Commission for relief, claiming that the company’s actions constituted unfair dismissal. The Commission held that the termination of the employment relationship was not a unilateral dismissal by the employer, but a termination by mutual agreement between the parties, and therefore found that unfair dismissal was not established. Ⅱ. Summary of Issues The issue in this case is whether, in circumstances where, after a meeting, payroll settlement was carried out and the access card was returned, the termination of the employment relationship constituted a unilateral dismissal by the employer, or a mutual termination (termination by agreement) between the employee and the employer. Ⅲ. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Findings The panel in this case found that there was no explicit and objective evidence that the employer had expressed a definitive intention to dismiss, that the employee had not directly confirmed with the representative director whether he had been dismissed, and that the request to return the access card came from an employee scheduled to resign, not from a person with personnel authority or from management. The panel further noted that the employee took the lead in payroll settlement by preparing and submitting a memo specifying his working days, pre‑tax and post‑tax salary, 3.3% withholding, and the bank account for receipt of payment; that two days before the meeting the employer had sent text messages to major clients introducing the employee’s successor in charge; and that the employee himself stated that, even up to the date of the meeting, while receiving handover of duties, he did not recognize any signs of an impending dismissal. In light of all these circumstances, the panel held that it was difficult to find that there had been a dismissal based on the employer’s unilateral intention, and that the employment relationship had been terminated by mutual agreement between the parties. Accordingly, it determined that “there was no dismissal.” Ⅳ. Practical Points (From the Employee’s Perspective) Even if an employee subjectively feels that he or she has been unfairly dismissed, if the employee subsequently takes the lead in payroll settlement or prepares and submits a memo premised on resignation and settlement, there is a high risk that the Labor Relations Commission will evaluate the situation as a “termination by agreement.” To assert that a dismissal notice was given, the employee should secure evidence by recording, for example, the specific dismissal remarks, the method of notification, and the process of confirmation, through notes, recordings, and similar means. Ⅴ. Practical Points (From the Employer’s Perspective) Employers should recognize that, in unfair dismissal disputes, the key issue is whether the termination of the employment relationship is a dismissal, a resignation, or a termination by agreement, and should clearly document the content of meetings and the circumstances leading to termination. In particular, in cases of individual termination by agreement rather than collective redundancies or restructuring, obtaining documents such as a settlement memo in which the employee personally records the conditions, or a resignation/termination‑by‑agreement confirmation, can serve as important defensive material when the existence of a dismissal is later disputed before the Labor Relations Commission or the courts. In this type of case, it is advisable to prevent unfair dismissal disputes by obtaining assistance from experts such as Labor Law Firm Law&, accurately understanding the legal distinctions and burden‑of‑proof structure among dismissal, resignation, and termination by agreement, and organizing evidence in advance. 2. Matters Determined A. Case Overview and Procedural History This is a case in which it was determined that there was no dismissal, on the grounds that the employment relationship was terminated by mutual agreement between the parties. 3. Summary of the Decision A. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Findings (1) There was no evidence to recognize that the employer had expressed a definitive intention to dismiss; (2) the employee had not directly confirmed with the representative director whether he had been dismissed; (3) the request to return the access card was made by an employee scheduled to resign, not by the representative director or an executive director; (4) the employee took the lead in payroll settlement by preparing and submitting to the employer a memo specifying his working days, pre‑tax and post‑tax salary, 3.3% withholding, and the receiving account; and (5) two days before the meeting, the employer sent text messages to major clients introducing the employee’s successor in charge, and the employee himself stated that, even up to the date of the meeting, he was receiving handover of duties and did not sense any signs of dismissal. In light of all of this, it was difficult to find that the employment relationship had been terminated by the employer’s unilateral intention, and therefore it was determined that there was no dismissal. [See More Related Decisions] - “Determination on Unfair Dismissal Relating to ‘Expectation of Employment Succession (Logistics Center Competitive Bidding)’” - “Determination on Unfair Dismissal Relating to ‘Expression of Intent to Resign (Resignation Remark in Telephone Call)’” - “Determination on Unfair Dismissal Relating to ‘Benefit of Remedy · Refusal to Re‑Employ (Post‑Retirement Fixed‑Term Employment)’” [Tags] Unfair dismissal, existence of dismissal (payroll settlement memo), others, Labor Law Firm Law&, large labor law firm, Samseong‑dong labor law firm, Samseong Station labor law firm, Gangnam labor law firm ※ This article is one of the “Unfair Dismissal Decisions” series by Labor Law Firm Law&. ※ You can view the previous article, “Determination on Unfair Dismissal Relating to ‘Refusal to Follow Work Allocation Order (Already Fixed Driving Assignment)’,” in a new window. ※ The list of decisions relating to existence of dismissal (payroll settlement memo) can be viewed together at “List of Decisions Relating to Existence of Dismissal (Payroll Settlement Memo).” ※ Korean version of this case: Korean article
    ⚙