Corporate trends / Performance record
Unfair Dismissal Precedent Relating to “Disciplinary Severity (Concurrent Employment, Breach of Fiduciary Duty, Document Leakage)” (Unfair Dismissal 850)
- Date2026/11/22 00:00
- Read 3
[Case Information]
This case is a precedent on the issue of “disciplinary severity (concurrent employment, breach of fiduciary duty, document leakage)” that was concluded under case number 2026부해738.
Decision date: 2026-10-06 · Decision body: Gyeongnam Regional Labor Relations Commission · Case No.: 2026부해738
Key issue summary:
A. Legitimacy of the grounds for discipline
Engaging in other work without the company’s permission, committing a breach of fiduciary duty in the course of work, allowing third parties to inspect company documents without the company’s permission, and disturbing workplace order all fall under the grounds for dismissal set out in Article 113 of the Rules of Employment. It was therefore held that the employer’s reliance on these acts as grounds for discipline was appropriate.
1. Legal Implications
Ⅰ. Case Overview
In this unfair dismissal case, the employee was dismissed for cause after being accused of engaging in other work without the company’s permission, committing a breach of fiduciary duty in the course of work, and allowing company documents to be viewed externally without authorization, thereby disturbing workplace order. The employee then filed for relief with the Labor Relations Commission.
The Gyeongnam Regional Labor Relations Commission comprehensively examined whether the conduct fell within the dismissal grounds under the Rules of Employment, whether the level of discipline was excessively severe, and whether the disciplinary procedure was lawful, in order to determine whether the employer’s disciplinary dismissal was justified.
Ⅱ. Summary of Issues
The issue in this case is:
“In a situation where concurrent employment, breach of fiduciary duty, leakage of company documents, and acts disturbing workplace order are all established, whether the disciplinary dismissal constitutes an excessively severe sanction that is manifestly unreasonable by social standards, and whether any procedural defects in the disciplinary process render the dismissal unfair.”
Ⅲ. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Reasoning
The panel in this case found that the acts relied upon by the employer as grounds for discipline—concurrent employment and engagement in profit-making activities, breach of fiduciary duty in the course of work, unauthorized inspection and leakage of company documents, and acts disturbing workplace order—all fall within the grounds for dismissal set out in Article 113 of the Rules of Employment.
Taking into account the nature and degree of the employee’s misconduct, the employee’s position, the impact on the company, and the extent of damage to the relationship of trust, the panel held that it was difficult to view the dismissal as a sanction that was manifestly unreasonable by social standards.
The panel also noted that the prescribed disciplinary procedures were observed, including convening the Personnel Committee in accordance with the Rules of Employment, Personnel Committee Regulations, and Disciplinary Handling Procedures, granting the employee an opportunity to appear and present explanations before the Personnel Committee, and notifying the employee of the Committee’s resolution.
Accordingly, the dismissal in this case was held to be justified, as grounds for discipline existed, the level of discipline could not be regarded as excessive, and there were no defects in the disciplinary procedure.
With respect to the assessment of disciplinary severity, the Labor Relations Commission applied the Supreme Court’s principle that a disciplinary measure is void as an abuse of discretion only where it is manifestly unreasonable by social standards. In other words, it comprehensively reviewed all relevant circumstances—such as the nature of the duties, the content and character of the misconduct, the purpose of maintaining work discipline through the sanction, the impact on corporate order, the employee’s position, and past work attitude—and, unless the measure was objectively and clearly unjust, it respected the employer’s discretion in discipline and upheld the legitimacy of the dismissal.
Ⅳ. Practical Points (From the Employee’s Perspective)
Employees must be clearly aware that provisions in the company’s Rules of Employment prohibiting concurrent employment and profit-making activities, prohibiting breaches of fiduciary duty, prohibiting external leakage of documents, and prohibiting acts disturbing workplace order can constitute serious grounds for discipline up to and including dismissal.
In particular, engaging in other work without the company’s express permission, or using company assets or information for personal gain or for the benefit of third parties, is an area in which the Labor Relations Commission and the courts readily acknowledge the legitimacy of disciplinary dismissal.
When an opportunity is provided during the disciplinary process to appear before the Personnel Committee and present explanations, it is important to actively contest the facts at that stage and submit favorable evidence. At the subsequent Labor Relations Commission stage, rather than relying solely on “procedural violations,” employees should comprehensively explain the existence and degree of the alleged misconduct, their work attitude, and any remorse, and specifically argue and prove that the level of discipline is excessive.
Ⅴ. Practical Points (From the Employer/Company Perspective)
From the employer’s standpoint, it is important to set out in concrete terms in the Rules of Employment the grounds for disciplinary dismissal, such as concurrent employment and profit-making activities, breaches of fiduciary duty, document leakage, and acts disturbing workplace order, and, when actually imposing discipline, to clearly link the factual circumstances to the relevant provisions.
Internal standards for the level of discipline should also be established so that a consistent level of sanctions is maintained for similar cases, thereby preventing disputes over fairness and allegations of abuse of discretion.
On the procedural side, it is essential to faithfully implement, in accordance with the Rules of Employment and personnel regulations, the composition of the disciplinary committee, prior notice, the opportunity to appear and present explanations, and the resolution and notification procedures. Since the Labor Relations Commission regards compliance with procedure, in addition to the grounds and level of discipline, as an essential requirement for the legitimacy of a dismissal, even seemingly minor procedural steps must be carried out without omission, and the process should be documented and retained.
This decision by the Gyeongnam Regional Labor Relations Commission clearly illustrates that, for conduct such as concurrent employment, breach of fiduciary duty, and document leakage, which fundamentally undermines the relationship of trust with the company, even the severe sanction of disciplinary dismissal may be recognized as justified.
To prevent unfair dismissal disputes and ensure lawful and appropriate HR and labor management, it is advisable to obtain sufficient prior advice on organizing grounds for discipline, designing disciplinary severity, and operating disciplinary procedures from a firm such as Labor Law Firm Law&.
2. Matters Decided
A. Case Overview and Procedural History
A case in which it was held that grounds for discipline existed, the level of discipline could not be regarded as excessive, and the disciplinary procedure was free from defects, so that the dismissal was justified.
3. Summary of Decision
A. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Reasoning
A. Legitimacy of the Grounds for Discipline
The acts of engaging in other work without the company’s permission, committing a breach of fiduciary duty in the course of work, allowing third parties to inspect company documents without the company’s permission, and disturbing workplace order all fall under the grounds for dismissal set out in Article 113 of the Rules of Employment. It is therefore deemed appropriate that the employer relied on these acts as grounds for discipline.
B. Appropriateness of the Level of Discipline
Considering the nature and degree of the employee’s misconduct, the employee’s position, the impact on the company, and the extent of damage to the relationship of trust, it is difficult to view the measure as a sanction that is manifestly unreasonable by social standards or as a departure from, or abuse of, the employer’s discretion in discipline.
C. Legality of the Disciplinary Procedure
The disciplinary procedure was conducted in accordance with the provisions of the Rules of Employment, Personnel Committee Regulations, and Disciplinary Handling Procedures; the employee was given an opportunity to appear before the Personnel Committee and present explanations; and the resolution of the Personnel Committee was notified. It is therefore determined that the relevant procedures were observed.
[See More Related Precedents]
- “Unfair Dismissal Precedent Relating to ‘Disciplinary Severity (Participation in Services for Another Institution)’”
- “Unfair Dismissal Precedent Relating to ‘Excessive Disciplinary Severity (Negligent Supervision/Management)’”
- “Unfair Dismissal Precedent Relating to ‘Refusal to Follow Dispatch Instructions (Already Fixed Duty Assignment)’” – Decision date: 2026-10-06
[Tags]
Unfair dismissal, disciplinary severity (concurrent employment · breach of fiduciary duty · document leakage), disciplinary dismissal, violation of company policies · non-compliance with work orders, Labor Law Firm Law&, large labor law firm, Samseong-dong labor law firm, Samseong Station labor law firm, Gangnam labor law firm
※ This article is part of the “Unfair Dismissal Precedents” series by Labor Law Firm Law&.
※ The previous article, “Unfair Dismissal Precedent Relating to ‘Existence of Dismissal (Payroll Settlement Memo)’,” can be viewed in a new window.
※ The list of precedents relating to disciplinary severity (concurrent employment, breach of fiduciary duty, document leakage) can be viewed together under “List of Precedents Relating to Disciplinary Severity (Concurrent Employment · Breach of Fiduciary Duty · Document Leakage).”
※ Korean version of this case: Korean article
