Labor law firm Law&

Corporate performance /
Consultation inquiry

    Corporate trends / Performance record

    Unfair Dismissal Decision on “Disciplinary Severity (Reposting Job Advertisements and False Reporting)” (Unfair Dismissal 852)
    • Date2026/11/23 00:00
    • Read 3
    [Case Information] This case is a decision on the issue of “disciplinary severity (reposting job advertisements and false reporting),” concluded under case number 2026BuHae656. Decision date: 2026-10-02 · Decision body: Central Labor Relations Commission · Case No.: 2026BuHae656 Key issue summary: A. Justifiability of grounds for discipline Although the employer clearly conveyed its intention that recruitment-related work would be handled by the corporation, the employee posted job advertisements on the corporation’s website and on external recruitment sites. Thereafter, even after the chairperson of the board instructed that the advertisements be deleted, the employee reposted the job advertisements and, in the course of doing so, made a false report. As these facts were confirmed, the grounds for discipline were found to be established. 1. Legal Implications Ⅰ. Case Overview This unfair dismissal case is a disciplinary matter in which the employer prevailed before the Central Labor Relations Commission, and in which the Commission found that the grounds for discipline, the level of discipline, and the disciplinary procedures were all justified. The employee received a three‑month salary reduction as discipline for independently posting job advertisements despite the employer’s instruction that the corporation would exclusively handle recruitment work, and for making a false report in the process of reposting the advertisements after being instructed to delete them. The employee filed a relief application with the Labor Relations Commission, but it was dismissed. As with many unfair dismissal and disciplinary cases handled by Labor Law Firm Law&, this case is a typical type of dispute in which, in assessing the legitimacy of discipline, not only the existence of grounds for discipline but also the appropriateness of the level of discipline and the lawfulness of the disciplinary procedures conducted after the amendment of the rules of employment were all at issue. Ⅱ. Summary of Issues The issues in this case are: “Whether a three‑month salary reduction imposed for repeatedly violating the employer’s instructions to centralize recruitment work and to delete job advertisements, and for making a false report in that process, is excessively severe by social standards, and whether the re‑disciplinary procedures conducted after the amendment of the rules of employment were unlawful.” Ⅲ. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Findings The panel in this case found that the employer had clearly conveyed its intention that recruitment‑related work would be handled by the corporation; that, notwithstanding this, the employee posted job advertisements on the corporation’s website and on external recruitment sites; that, even after the chairperson of the board instructed that the advertisements be deleted, the employee reposted the advertisements and, in the course of doing so, made a false report; and that these facts were objectively confirmed. In light of this, the panel held that the grounds for discipline were justified. The panel also noted that, in the prior disciplinary action, the employer had initially considered a demotion but mitigated the sanction to suspension from duty, and that, reflecting the purport of the first‑instance Local Labor Relations Commission decision, the employer further reduced the level of discipline to a three‑month salary reduction. Taking this into account, together with the fact that the mitigation provision was a discretionary provision left to the employer’s judgment, the panel concluded that it was difficult to regard the three‑month salary reduction as an excessively severe sanction that was clearly unreasonable by social standards. In addition, the panel found that, after the prior disciplinary disposition was set aside by the first‑instance Local Labor Relations Commission, the employer amended the rules of employment through lawful procedures; that, pursuant to the amended rules of employment, the employer convened a personnel committee to deliberate and resolve on whether to impose discipline; and that, in that process, the employee was given an opportunity to present his or her views. Considering these circumstances as a whole, the panel held that it was difficult to regard the amendment of the rules of employment as unlawful, and that it was likewise difficult to find that the disciplinary procedures conducted by applying the amended rules of employment in force at the time of the re‑discipline were unlawful. Ⅳ. Practical Points (From the Employee’s Perspective) From the employee’s perspective, it should be borne in mind that repeatedly violating the employer’s instructions concerning personnel and recruitment, or making false reports on the progress of such matters, is not a mere minor infraction but can fully constitute grounds for discipline. In particular, even if a disciplinary measure has once been set aside, the employer may lawfully amend the rules of employment and, after following proper procedures, impose discipline again. One should therefore not be complacent in thinking, “It was canceled once, so it is over.” In assessing the appropriateness of the level of discipline, the Labor Relations Commission and the courts take a comprehensive view of the nature of the duties, the content and character of the misconduct, the impact on corporate order, the employee’s past disciplinary history, and the circumstances of any mitigation. Accordingly, it is necessary to formulate a response strategy that considers how one’s conduct has affected trust and hierarchy within the organization, and whether the company has already taken mitigating measures on multiple occasions. Ⅴ. Practical Points (From the Employer’s/Company’s Perspective) From the employer’s side, to secure the legitimacy of a disciplinary disposition, first, the factual circumstances constituting the grounds for discipline should be clearly preserved through objective materials such as documents and electronic records. Second, with respect to the level of discipline, the employer should determine the sanction, based on the standards for disciplinary severity in the rules of employment and reward‑and‑punishment regulations, by comprehensively considering the seriousness and repetitiveness of the misconduct and the nature of the duties, at a level that cannot easily be regarded as excessively severe by social standards. If there are circumstances of mitigation, the process leading to mitigation should also be documented. Third, in terms of disciplinary procedures, when amending the rules of employment, the employer must comply with the lawful procedures under the Labor Standards Act (hearing employees’ opinions, filing reports, etc.), and must faithfully implement the procedural requirements set out in the regulations, such as convening and resolving a disciplinary committee and providing an opportunity for the employee to present his or her views. Even where there are sufficient grounds for discipline, many cases are overturned as unfair dismissal or unfair discipline due to procedural defects or excessively severe sanctions. Therefore, as in this case, it is very important for preventing disputes that employers review and prepare in advance to meet the standards required by law. 2. Matters Decided A. Case Overview and Procedural History This is a case in which it was held that the grounds for discipline were established, that the level of discipline could not easily be regarded as excessively severe by social standards, and that the disciplinary procedures were not unlawful. 3. Summary of the Decision A. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Findings (1) Justifiability of Grounds for Discipline Although the employer clearly conveyed its intention that recruitment‑related work would be handled by the corporation, the employee posted job advertisements on the corporation’s website and on external recruitment sites. Thereafter, even after the chairperson of the board instructed that the advertisements be deleted, the employee reposted the job advertisements, and it was confirmed that the employee made a false report in the course of doing so. Accordingly, the grounds for discipline are established. (2) Appropriateness of the Level of Discipline In the prior disciplinary action, the employer initially considered a disciplinary measure at the level of demotion but mitigated it to suspension from duty, and, reflecting the purport of the first‑instance Local Labor Relations Commission decision, further reduced the level of discipline to a three‑month salary reduction. Taking this into account, together with the fact that the mitigation provision was discretionary, it is difficult to regard the three‑month salary reduction in this case as an excessively severe disposition that is clearly unreasonable by social standards. (3) Lawfulness of the Disciplinary Procedures After the prior disciplinary disposition was set aside by the first‑instance Local Labor Relations Commission, the employer amended the rules of employment through lawful procedures, and, pursuant to the amended rules of employment, convened a personnel committee to deliberate and resolve on whether to impose discipline, and gave the employee an opportunity to present his or her views. Considering these circumstances as a whole, it is difficult to regard the amendment of the rules of employment as unlawful, and it is likewise difficult to find that conducting the disciplinary procedures by applying the amended rules of employment in force at the time of the re‑discipline was unlawful. [See More Related Decisions] - “Unfair Dismissal Decision on ‘Disciplinary Severity (Participation in Services for Another Institution)’” - “Unfair Dismissal Decision on ‘Excessive Disciplinary Severity (Negligent Management and Supervision)’” - “Unfair Dismissal Decision on ‘Business Necessity (Reassignment of Cleaning Staff)’” [Tags] Unfair dismissal, disciplinary severity (reposting job advertisements and false reporting), violation of company policies · noncompliance with work instructions, disciplinary dismissal, Labor Law Firm Law&, large labor law firm, Samseong‑dong labor law firm, Samseong Station labor law firm, Gangnam labor law firm ※ This article is part of the “Unfair Dismissal Decisions” series by Labor Law Firm Law&. ※ The previous article, “Unfair Dismissal Decision on ‘Limitation on Application of the Law (Fewer than Five Regular Employees)’,” can be viewed in a new window. ※ The list of decisions related to disciplinary severity (reposting job advertisements and false reporting) can be viewed together on the page “List of Decisions Related to Disciplinary Severity (Reposting Job Advertisements and False Reporting).” ※ Korean version of this case: Korean article
    ⚙