Labor law firm Law&

Corporate performance /
Consultation inquiry

    Corporate trends / Performance record

    Unfair Dismissal Case Involving “Revocation of Hiring (Notification by Text Message)” (Unfair Dismissal 853)
    • Date2026/11/23 00:00
    • Read 3
    [Case Information] This case is a decision concerning the issue of “revocation of hiring (notification by text message),” concluded under case number 2026부해163. Decision date: 2026-10-02 · Decision body: Jeju Regional Labor Relations Commission · Case No.: 2026부해163 Summary of key issues: A. Whether the revocation of hiring constitutes a dismissal: Even if a written employment contract has not been executed, where the employer has notified the applicant of final acceptance and has agreed with the worker on wages, duties, place of work, start date, etc., an employment contract is deemed to have been formed, and any subsequent revocation of hiring constitutes a dismissal. 1. Legal Implications Ⅰ. Case Overview In this case, after completing all recruitment procedures and notifying the applicant of final acceptance, the employer agreed with the prospective hire on wages, place of work, start date, and other terms, and then unilaterally notified the revocation of hiring by text message. The worker filed an application for relief from unfair dismissal. The Jeju Regional Labor Relations Commission focused on whether this revocation of hiring constituted a dismissal after the formation of an employment contract, and on whether the dismissal was justified and complied with the statutory requirement of written notice. This case illustrates that, in unfair dismissal disputes, the legal nature of the hiring-confirmation stage and the method of giving notice of dismissal are treated as important issues. It also showcases the practical approach of the Labor Relations Commission and the accumulated know‑how of Labor Law Firm Law& in handling disputes related to hiring and dismissal. Ⅱ. Issues The issues in this case are whether an employment contract is formed even before a written contract is signed, if there has been a final acceptance notice and agreement on wages and other working conditions, and whether a subsequent revocation of hiring notified by text message constitutes a “dismissal” under the Labor Standards Act, thereby becoming subject to an application for relief from unfair dismissal. Ⅲ. Summary of the Labor Relations Commission’s Decision The panel in this case noted that the employer had completed the recruitment process and notified the applicant of final acceptance; that specific agreements had been reached regarding wages, duties, place of work, start date, etc.; and that, although no written employment contract had been executed, these circumstances, taken together, supported the conclusion that an employment contract had already been formed. Accordingly, the text message revoking the hiring sent to the prospective hire was deemed, in substance, to be a unilateral notice by the employer terminating the employment relationship, i.e., a dismissal. In addition, the revocation text message did not state specific grounds for dismissal, thereby violating the obligation under Article 27 of the Labor Standards Act to provide written notice of the reasons for dismissal. Furthermore, the actual ground asserted for the revocation—an inquiry about the possibility of improving the accommodation provided during the training period—could not be regarded as an objective and reasonable reason sufficient to justify termination of the employment contract. On this basis, the Commission held that the dismissal in this case lacked both procedural and substantive justification and therefore constituted an unfair dismissal. Ⅳ. Practical Points (From the Worker’s Perspective) From the worker’s standpoint, it is important to bear in mind that an employment contract may be deemed to have been formed even without signing a written contract, if you have received a final acceptance notice and have specifically agreed on key working conditions such as wages, place of work, and start date. If, after this stage, the employer unilaterally revokes the hiring—even if the notice is given by text message or messenger—this may be evaluated as a dismissal under the Labor Standards Act. Where the reasons for dismissal are not specifically notified in writing or there is no just cause, you may consider filing an application for relief from unfair dismissal with the Labor Relations Commission. Moreover, if hiring has been revoked because you exercised your legitimate rights or made reasonable requests related to your living conditions during the recruitment process (for example, inquiries about accommodation conditions, questions regarding working hours or wages), it is advisable to carefully review, together with a labor law expert, whether the grounds asserted by the employer can truly be regarded as objective and reasonable. Ⅴ. Practical Points (From the Employer’s Perspective) From the employer’s perspective, it must be clearly recognized that an employment contract can be formed once final acceptance has been notified and working conditions have been agreed, regardless of whether written documents have been executed, and that any subsequent revocation of hiring will in effect be treated as a dismissal. Even where it is unavoidable to revoke hiring at the hiring-confirmation stage, the employer must have objective and reasonable grounds that satisfy the “just cause” requirement under Article 23 of the Labor Standards Act and must strictly comply with the procedure in Article 27 of the same Act by providing written notice specifying the concrete reasons for dismissal. To prepare for situations in which grounds for revoking hiring may arise—such as redundancy, managerial reasons, or failure to meet qualification requirements—it is helpful for dispute prevention to clearly include provisions reserving the right to rescind in job postings, hiring-confirmation notices, and work rules, while ensuring that such provisions do not conflict with the dismissal restrictions under the Labor Standards Act. In doing so, employers are advised to obtain prior advice from specialized institutions such as Labor Law Firm Law&. 2. Matters Decided A. Case Overview and Procedural History This case held that notifying a prospective hire—who had been informed of final acceptance through the recruitment process and had agreed on wages, place of work, start date, etc.—of the revocation of hiring by text message constituted a unilateral termination of the employment relationship after the formation of an employment contract and therefore amounted to a dismissal. Because no specific reasons for dismissal were provided in writing and no just cause was recognized, the dismissal was found to be unfair. 3. Gist of the Decision A. Whether the Revocation of Hiring Constitutes a Dismissal Even if a written employment contract has not been executed, in light of the fact that the employer notified the worker of final acceptance and agreed with the worker on wages, duties, place of work, start date, etc., an employment contract is deemed to have been formed, and the subsequent revocation of hiring constitutes a dismissal. B. Whether the Obligation to Provide Written Notice of the Reasons for Dismissal Was Observed Because the text message revoking hiring did not state specific reasons for dismissal, this constitutes a violation of the obligation under Article 27 of the Labor Standards Act to provide written notice of the reasons for dismissal. C. Whether There Was Just Cause for Dismissal Furthermore, the content actually asserted by the employer as the ground for revocation of hiring (an inquiry about the possibility of improving the accommodation provided by the employer during the training period) cannot be regarded as an objective and reasonable reason sufficient to justify termination of the employment contract. D. Conclusion The revocation of hiring after the formation of the employment contract constitutes a dismissal, and because specific reasons for dismissal were not provided in writing and no just cause was recognized, it amounts to an unfair dismissal. [See More Related Decisions] - Unfair dismissal decision concerning “Relief Interest · Refusal to Rehire (Post‑Retirement Fixed‑Term Employment)” - Unfair dismissal decision concerning “Business Necessity (Reassignment of Cleaning Staff)” - Unfair dismissal decision concerning “Excessive Disciplinary Measure (Negligence in Management and Supervision)” [Tags] Unfair dismissal, revocation of hiring (notification by text message), others, Labor Law Firm Law&, large labor law firm, Samseong‑dong labor law firm, Samseong Station labor law firm, Gangnam labor law firm ※ This article is part of the “Unfair Dismissal Decisions” series by Labor Law Firm Law&. ※ You can view the previous article, “Unfair dismissal decision concerning ‘Disciplinary Measure (Reposting Job Advertisement · False Report)’,” in a new window. ※ A list of decisions related to revocation of hiring (notification by text message) can be found under “List of decisions related to revocation of hiring (notification by text message).” ※ Korean version of this case: Korean article
    ⚙